The Archive · 1929

Insistence on the Law

"Lam in aympathly with your stutem your reply dated the &th instant that both the Judges and the Senior Consul's Deputies should yeeeive the same—respect from persons inthe court, but 1 disagree with your claim that the Senior Consul's Deputies may forbid Jawyers £0 appear in cow the consent of the huygens bocuaye the lave cour ing to the actions in court must be according to lay.

"Phe sitting of Senior Consuls Deputies in the court is based on the Rendition Agreement. There is no provision in the Rendition Agreement that the Senior Consul's Deputies may punish lawyers without the consent of the Judges.

"You have admitted that it is' the Judge's vight to maintain order and to direct the legal proceedings. in the court, and only the Judges, and mot the Senior Consul's Deputies, ave entitled to deal with the Lowyerx who have misconducted themselves in court may he forbid= den to speak or forbidden to practise in court or handed over to the Lawyers' Punishment Commission for. punishment, but all this must be carried out according to the Chinese laws for the organization of law courts, and the regulations governing layyers. Tudges who are empowered, to deal with lave must out. these punishments according to the laws. and the Senior Consul's Deputies who are not empowered to do x0 have violated the Rendition agreement in doing 50, The Judge's Rights "Moreover, in connection with Mr, Tsu Zu-cheng's conduct in court, Judge Kuh ordered Mr. something ing to Art, Laws of Courts the steps taken by Suze Kuh were perfectly texas and Mad Mr. Ts continued that manner, it Kuh ache should wi him. Me, Van den fore Judge Kuh spoke, ordered torsion police to eM. Tstt from the court Ww out the consent of Judge Kuh.

"tu addition Mr, Van den Ber wrote at suspension onder on the charge sheet suspending Mr. Tsu for three months. By this he eneroachet not only on the judges?

ights but also on the rights of the members of the Lawyers' Punish ment Commission. und disturbed the order in the court, That why T was requested the whole boa of judyes to requests on to onder My. Van den Berg to anew that ma stich would be cated.

The Refusal to Sit "The whole body of judges will longer permit these illegal actions by Mr, Van den Berg, and. until this question has been settled will refuse to sit with Mr. Van den Berg in court. At the same time the. Kiangsu Provincial Government has been requested to open negotiations: with the Consular Body in this connection.

The Shanghai Chinese Bar Association has" passed a resolution asking: the Commissioner for Forsign Affairs to refuse Mr. Van den Berg, seat on the Bench of the Court and to declare all records made oft by him in the case of Mr. Tsu Zuching null and void,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account