Sept. 21.
Four of the largest cinema theatres in Shanghai have now installed talking film apparatus and, to judge by the advertise ments of forthcoming produc~ tions seen at a recent visit, another house is beginning waver from its brave resolve to stick to the silent screen, Whether the "talkies" really are to public taste, or only attract by novelty, we do not pretend to but undoubtedly they draw enormous audiences. Improvement must be admitted in some of the most recently shown talking films, At the outset they were so monstrously grotesque that one did not know whether to roar at their ridiculousness or weep over thefr, utter imbecility, But either' better machines have been imported or operators have learnt better how to manage them, The point has been reached at which it is possible to form some opinion as to whether the "talkies" will prove gain or loss to the art of the cinema, There is no need to dwell upon their may defects, still obvious and even painful, It is evident that the same recording machine cannot cope with all voices alike, Some come through passably well, others are a mere indistinguishable blur. Women's voices, for some reason, appear to fare worst and are rarely intelligible. Everybody lispe; and one con-Jectures that it will be advisable to train operators to. raise or lower the pitch of the mont for successive speakers, ince what is all right for one is gross distortion for another. Surprise has been expressed that 80 few of the "stars" were able to speak for the "talkies." But this is in no way wonderful. Anyone who has had experience in public speaking knows how much practice is needed in order to acquire the proper control of the voice. 'This, on the stage, becomes an absolute art, as abundantly revealed by' the marked difference between am-atour actors and professionals. To talk for the films, one may imagine, is even more exacting. For the mechanical recorder is incapable of the allowances which the human ear continually makes and every recorded blemish is, of course, magnified in reproduction, But it may be taken for granted that the clever people who discovered how to convert sound into light and then back again will not rest until they have made their invention as perfect as possible, Another defect of the talking films may be mentioned as one to which producers will no doubt ultimately awake. In the pre vailing passion for dialogue they would seem almost deliberately to have thrown away advantages in which the silent film is unrivalled. Take, for instance, its amazing power of suggestion. "Ladies of the Mob", as a whole, though quite a good picture, is nothing out of the way.
But the execution in the prologue is': one of the finest things we have seen, Yet one sees nothing of the execution itself: the collapse of the prisoner as he is led to the fatal chair is the nearest we get to it, and even then, by a stroke of genius, we are shown: no more than his and the w ders' legs. Otherwise, practi. cally nothing but the faces of those who have to attend the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.