The Archive · 1923

Armed Robberies

The suggestions made by Chinese merchants for dealing with the armed robbery evil in Shanghai are in one respect at least fully justified by the facts of the ease. This is that capita] punishment should be meted out to alli of those convicted, instead of, as in the great majority of cases nowa sentence of imprisonment being passed. The Western outlook humanity and its misdeeds makes it difficult to support a scheme which seems to allow of no alternative to the death penalty, but we are-face to face with an evil whose magnitude has become more pronounced each succeeding year and which shows no tendency to be curbed by the infliction even of long sentences of imprisonment. It is already the practice of the Mixed Court to send the worst offenders to the Arsenal, where the death penalty is carried out, but the numbers who have thus paid to the utmost for their crimes is apparently not large enough to act as a real deterrent, and if so, incarceration in the Municipal Gaol must hold no tertors for the culprits.. The Chiinese merchants in their petition now ask that alli these criminals be dealt with "according to Chinese law," under which the death sentence is imposed for this special crime, and on the assumption that they know their countrymen a great deal Setter than we do, there seems a good case for giving heed to their suggestion. After all, the greater proportion of this bad giement come from outside the Settlement, and knowing what penalty would await them in their own locality, there need be no squeamishness in handing them back to their own authorities. The other suggestions by the merchants are by no means so readily approved of, and a proposal to arm watchmen with rifles would require very careful consideration prior to adoption.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account