An appeal against the jury's findings in a Kings Bench action in which Mr. David Seely, aged 18, son of Lord Mottistone, was awarded £4,000 damages for personal injuries, came before the Court of Appeal recently, and was dismissed.
The original action was before Mr. Justice Macnaghten on January 11, when the jury found in favour of Mr. Seely against the Hampshire and Dorset Motor Services, Bournemouth, owners of a motor coach which was involved "in a collision with Mr.
Seely's bicycle in the Isle of Wight, in 1935. In addition to the award io the injured boy, Lord Mottistone was awarded £743 17s. 4d. special damage Norman ott, K.C., appear: ing for the Hampshire and Dorset Moler Services, said the boy was cycling on an up-hill road, which had a steep camber The motor-coach travelling behind him in the same direction attempted to pass him, and the collision occured. It went to the off-side, in an endeavour to-avoid the cycle and finished up with its wheels in e hedge. ihe place where the accident occurred the hill became steeper, it might well be that the cyclist began to wobble. Because of his' head injury Mr. Seely could remember nothing of the accident.
"Wheeled Juggernaut"
Their Lordships, Mr. Birkett con tinued, would appreciate the difficulty in which Sir Patrick Hastings, K.C. (counsel for Mr. Seely) found him-, self at the trial Sir Patrick said frankly to the jury that he did not know how the accident occurred; he could only surmise. He went on, however, to make suggestions which, in Mr. Birkett's submission, laid a bias from which the case never recovered.
The motor-coach was described by Sir Patrick as a "wheeled juggernaut" trying to pass the be; thing which the driver ought never to have done."
The effect produced upon the jury by that sort of atmosphere was such that they never recovered from it suggested Mr, Birkett, and the Judge, in his summing-up, ought to have pointed out to the jury that the coach driver had a perfect right to be there.
Mr. Birkett added that he was taking the point that, in all the circumstances of the case, the damages awarded were excessive, Lord Justice Greer, at the conclusion of Mr. Birkett's submissions, intimated that their Lordships desir ed to hear Sir Patrick Hastings (for the respondents) only on the point of the suggested non-direction of the y s to the effect of contributory
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.