The Archive · 1936

Interesting Legal Submission

'The submission that the definition of an affray was the fighting of two fr more persons to the terror of His Majesty's. subjects was made by Mr. Morris' Diamond, for the defence, when the prosecution was closed.

Mr, Morris submitted that the police would find it hard to bring before the Court any of His Majesty's suva Jeets who had been terrorized, and that, therefore, the charges, brought the Indians of being concerned fray were wrong, With re-to the charges of assault, the police had produced only one witness whose evidence had any bearing on the case, This man. was Mr, Reeks, also for the defence, said he had no submission to make, but he would like to put his witnesses the box, so that they might produce truthful statements of the circumstances.

Wood for toe Aug. 20, The first defendant said he bought the piece of wood from a Chinese beg-

Mr. Diamond: My client can object "to that question on the grounds of privilege.

Mr. Livingstone: Is that a At piece of wood for your hoe?—Yes, To cultivate your vegetables with, or to hit other people on the head with. Do you mean to say that you buy a miserable piece of wood like this, und take it back three miles to your -home?—Yes, Defendant stated, in reply to a question, that he visited a number of shops on that afternoon, but he did not buy any cloth there because the price was 434 yards for $1, whereas he could buy it elsewhere for 5% yards for §1.

Mr, Livingstone: Why were you running away when the—police arrested you?—I was not running away. I was standing at the corner.

After you were arrested, why did you not tell the police that you were aking this stick home?—The police did not ask me.

You were locked up in prison for a week, were you not?—I was In risen for eleven days, Did you not consider it a grave miscarriage of justice that you were locked up for eleven days because you had bought a piece of wood for Your hoe?—No one asked me, so I id not tell.

You have to be asked before you will say that you are an. innocent man, gravely " maltreated. by. the {Police?—I was so worried when I was jail that 1 was thinking over all

serve it, the time what T had done to. de-Do you consider that, in 37 days, that is the best excuse you can make up?—No, that is not The next to give evidence was Kundar Singh," who stated that was 20 years of age, Mr. Livingstone, (in eross-examina-lon): Were you born in 1914?—T have stated my age about. I do not remember exactly when I was born.

'Witness was confronted' with a riding-crop, which, he said, cost him $5, "Rather a lot of money to pay for that stick, was it not?" queried Mr. Livingstone, replied the witness, "but I loved it, so T boughs it."

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account