cUSTOMS
June 18, The commonplace about history repeating itself was never better illustrated than in the case of General Yen Hsi-shan seizing the Customs at Tientsin, In December, 1923, the late Dr, Sun Yat-sen made precisely the same attempt. Point for point, line for line, the same arguments were used, the same procedure as how actually followed by General Yen threatened. The only difference is that in 1923 it was the South challenging Northern possession of the Customs fund now the positions: Andtin~1923" six Powers, Gi Britain, America, France, Italy, Japan and Portugal, sent some even or twelve gunboats to protect the Canton Custom House, mee. During the year 1919 and or part of 1920 the Diplomatic Body had agreed to his being Ulotted that part of the Customs avenue in Kuangtung which remained over after its proper fon in the payment of foreign lues borne by the Customs had wen deducted, Dr. Sun's argunent, like that of General Yen or day, was that what became he surplus after foreign claims Customs revenue for Boxer indemnity and loans had been satisfied, was China's business ind not the Powers'. In March 920 there was a coup d'état in canton Dr, Sun temporarily los:
hold on the city, his Foreign Minister, the late Dr. Wu Tinganit, fled taking the seals of fice with him, and the pay-rents of Customs money ceased. Vhether the Diplomatic Body vere wise or unwise in respect f\the concession they had made 1919 is open to doubt, The oint is that they had made it, ud thus gave ample ground for Ir. Sun's application for pay-rents to be renewed in Septem-ex, 1923, when he had re-esta-lished himself in Canton. But he. Diplomatic Body had had ime to think things over and changed their minds, Yashington in particular dispproved of any tampering with te-integrity of the Customs reence, The story of the correspond-nee between Dr, Sum and Peing is fully set out in a stateent issued at Canton on Decemer 19, 1923, in the name of Dr. an. It is too long to quote in all but the curious may find it n page 874 of the "North-China lorald" of December 29, 1923. he application for the Custon: s ency sent to Peking on Sep-mber 5, a8 mentioned above, as answered by telegram on september 28 to the effect that Diplomatic Body were ce: dering the matter. Nothing ither happened until Decem-ex 3 when a report that Dr. Sun tended to seize the Customs rew from the Diplomatic Body nother telegram warning him lat they could not countenance ay such act and, if necessary, ould use force to stop it. Can-m replied on the Sth thst no terference with the Customs as intended nor had any threat been made to take over its administration, but that "as its (Ganton's) Customs re-Yenues were remitted to Peking and there used so as to release other revenues for the financing of one military expedition after another against it, this Govern.
ment (Canton) intended to order the Customs authorities to cooss remitting to Peking and retain the funds for local se."
The statement went on to say that after the satisfaction of all claims on Customs revenue there remained an ample surplus, which the Peking Government had used for "a series of domes-tie loans....for purposes of elther war against the South or corruption and bribery in connection with sundry Presidentia) elections." Accordingly, Canton issued an order to the Inspector General "to retain at Canton or other places to be designated all Customs revenues collected within territory of this (Canton)
riment and, after providing for a proportionate share of ths funds required for the service of the foreign obligations charged on the Customs, to pay the same as may be onlered by this Gov.
A claim was added for pay mei of all arrears due on this basis since March, 1920, and a warning followed that If this order be not obeyed, this Government will proceed to appoint new Customs officials who will recognize its authority.
The Diplomatic Body would seem to have cautiously avoided being enmeshed in argument with the skilful dialecticians of Canton, Effective measures were taken and the Customs revenue was not, It is unnecessary to underline! the points in which the history of 1928 so faithfully anticipated that of 1930. But' one more Quotation from the leading article of those days may be permitted:
Thus the Powers are confronted with the alternative of coming into direct conflict with Dr. Sun, to an &tent which they "have never before been brought with of the Chinese political beligerents; or of allowing him to establish a precedent which would instantly be followed by every province in China... The mus advertised injustice is more apparent than real. After the ser vice of the foreign and domestic Joans there is very little if any surplus from the Customs....n0t, if the surplus were removed from the service of the domestic loans, would Peking's armed adventures be affected. If the surplus were not paid to the bondholders, the Iatier would simply have to 29 without... Thur' the Diplomatic Body's determination to prevent Dr. Sun from meddling with the Customs is at least as much undertaken in the interest of the Chinese people as of foreign bondholders, Mutatis mutandis those words are as applicable to-day as in 1923, only more so, in that the number and scope of the domestic loans has greatly increased in the past six years, Even if it could be said that those loans were raised to enable Nanking to make war on Peking—and. it cannot, since all these loans were floated prior to the present cor: flict—there still have to be con. sidered the interests of the Chi: nese who lent their money ip all innocence and good faith. 'The domestic loans secured on Customs revenue are the sheet anchor of the business world. If their stability is impaired, as it must be unless the seizure of the Tientsin Customs is strongly resisted, the resulting misery' among the Chinese people mus?! be very great: And: it may! well be recalled that friendship
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.