The Archive · 1931

(COURT OF CONSULS

Suit Against Council

The first hearing by the Court of Consuls -of the action brought "against the Shanghai Municipal

Edwards, took place in. the "Ad-Gouncil by its Seoretary, Mr. 8. ministration Building on March 43,'The Court consisted of Mr. J. van Haute, Consul-General for Belgium (President); Mr.

H. Groenman, Consul-Genera for. the Netherlands; Mr. J. Bi 1%, Consul-General for Great 1 Mr, Douglas Jenkins, Gonsul-General (in charge) for the United "States of. America and Mr, K, Murai, Consul-General for. Japan. 2 Some spirited passages occurred during the cross-examination of the petitioner: by. Counsel for the Sii.E' in one at these, petitioner the petitioner further ascribed suspension from duty "without prejudice" as being indirectly due to_an article which appeared in the "Showdown" "in connection with Mx, Fessenden's acceptance of the post of Director-General in March Petitioner, in his amended peti-bout June 7, engaged by' John the respondents' agents to join the service of had ever been held out as such by them.

Respondents also denied any! obligation to re-engage petitioner, or to renew his employment beyond September 30, 1982, and concluded that they were in no Way Tesponsible for the decision not to renew petitiener's agreement becoming public, or that, if it did, it was a breach of the agreement. It was asked that the petition should be dismissed with costs. for the petitioner; Mr.

Counsel: Mr. M. Reager Harris Wright, of Hansons, for the res: lent.

Outlining the case for the petitioner, Mr. Harris said that in June, 1923, "he '(the petitioner) had received a letter from Messrs. John] [Pook & C the Council's agents in [London inviting him to accept an appointment with the Council. /Simultaneously, he was considering] lan appointment which had offered him in connection with the National Savings movement in the Trish Free State. At an interview! with Mr. Percy Compton, one of the two partners of Messrs. John Pook & given to understand that while in accordance with {the Land Regulations of the International Settlement of Shanghai no leon tract. for ied in excess of three years. could be. considered, he ould rely' upon: any' appointment with the Council being of". per-Tanent natare inasmuch tial agreement for three years would be indefinitely renewed, subject only certain provisos regarding in-Jeompetency "and misconduct. In short, the petitioner had been given to understand that service with the the Secretariat Department of the Ce council was permanent service. "Shanghai Municipal Council. Dur-The other partner in Messrs. John Hing. the negotiations petitioner wa Pook' & Con, a Bir. Williams, had informed by partners of the abov' imparted identic information, firm that though under the term During the interview, the petition-of the Land Regulations a longer jer told both partners that he was agreement. than three years could Jo married man with. five children. Rot be entered into nevertheless hi The size of his tamil agreement would be renewed from to them and time to time unless, he proved in-|hi that they would have, to cable efficient, or was guilty of miteonnct, and that Service with the Shanghai Municipal Council was ways regarded. as permanent, Petitioner claimed that upon such hho was induced to such data to Shanghai. They did som ived the Council's assent to his employment, whereupon he we to, sign an undertaking "to "enter int three-year service, yising from "Senior Assistant 1924 to Secretary in 1926, which position a new agreement was signed on December 31, 1929, for n further three years at a monthly salary of Tls. 1,500.

On October 14, 1990, petitioner was informed by the Director: General that his existing agreement would not be renewed on expiry, and on October 20 this was con: firmed in. writing.

Petitioner claimed that such]

'a breach of the warranty' Couneit out to be a permanent tone, and that the respondents had not' shown or attempted to show any good cause for their decision.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account