The Archive · 1937

No Precedent For This Case

Mr, Nelson, in his summing up. said that there were many more in-Juries, than mere disfigurement, and the evidence showed that the peti-toner had suffered much pain and anguish, both physical and mental, The principal damage suffered was the Joss of her Job, and the possibility of her obtaining employment was practically nil, Referring to Mr.

quotation of Chinese law, said that the court wa lering Chinese lave, The mere fact that $4,680 was the highest award made against the Council. was of no consequence in this ease, and every case must rest on its own facts. There was no precedent which would assist in determining the result of the present action, Apparently, continued Mr. Nelson, was only because of the Unreasonable attitude of counsel for the clitioner that the Couneit had not paid damages. Why, then, did the municipal advocate contest the question of ability? The amount of the claim had been reduced because petitioner felt that her condition had. Improved, and if the court awarded the sum' claimed, petitioner would only be receiving a just "compensa~ tion for her injuries. giving judgment in plaintit's favour. the" Court' assessed the damages to be paid by the Council Ju the sum of $9400, including petitioner's costs. The Court costs of the case were ordered to be paid by the Council,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account