Grain gave judgment in favour of} Mr. Julius Rosenfeld in the proceedings—brought st Mr. Maurice Simmons and ordered the specific performance of a verbal Agreement entered into on January] judgment was {in full as. follows:
'The plaintiff states that on that date an agreement. was entered into in which the plaintiff—agreed to refrain from taking' legal - proceedings and. applying for -an Unjumetion "against the" defendant] for carrying on business in buying and Selling American, Chinese, and Indian cotton in China. contrary to an agreement entered Into between the defendant and J. Spant & Ca. fon, October 19, 1980, when the Aogendant dissolved." partnership with the two then members of the firm of J, Spunt & Ca, nantly, Jacob and Reuben Spunt.
The Plaintif™ also claims Ts. 10,- he first instalment to be paid to him under the said verbal agreement of january 12, 1931.
'The defendant does not admit that there was a verbal agreement, But that if there "was an agreement there was no consideration on the part of the plainti™ for such! agreement and if there was. an agreement it was dependant on the plaintiff' satisfying the defendant! that he, the plaintiff, was the owner: of the business J, Spunt & Ca., and that the plaintiff" would _indennity the defendant against any one else making. claims against him and! that "the "agreement. should be] embodied ina written "agreement! approved by both parties, is further pleaded by the defence that Sec, 4 of the Statute]
with, frauds has not been complied The history of the firm J. Spunt Ca, is as follows:—
'The original partners were Jacob Spunt and Rosenfeld, the father of the plaintiff, from about, 1908, 'About 1915 the defendant became 'a partner, Rosenfeld, the, father of] the plaintiff retired,' and Reubs Oi: became a partner about 1916.
1920, the defendant Simmons retired from the firm—his evidence that he was retire from the firm. He was! nid back his capital and his share outstanding profits, In 1928 Reuben. Spunt died and in 1929 Saco Spunt died. 'Then the pre-font plainti entered into an agree: ment with Mrs. Jacob Sunt to transfer the goodwill of J. Spunt' 4 Ca, to himself, that he should catty on the business and pay Mes, Sacob Spunt 25 per cent, of met profits and she was to be free From any abilities of the said fiom as long as the plaintiff? carried fon the business in the name of J. Spunt & Ca.
By the dissolution agreement of 1920 the defendant undertook that for 25 years from the date of the agreement, not to carry on business buying "or selling" American, Chinese and Indian Cotton, Goods and" certain other commodities in China, America or Canada unless vith the consent of the other parties' of the agreement that was Tacob Sand Reuben Spunt trading' og, F, Spunt & Ca.
The defendant was to receive captai standing to his credit in the fern, his proportion of undistributed profits and_ proportionate share of outstanding accounts.
the deed he was allowed to buy and sell cotton, cotton waste! and gar in America s0 long as he Bought and sold in America, He could dealing cotton in the three countries named, if he dealt, with the firm of Jacob and Reuben Spunt, Twill deal with the question of! legal consideration later.
The defendant then went to New York where he remained six years and returned to Shanghai in 1930, hho states at the invitation of Jacob Spunt, Before the defendant's arrival Jacob Spunt had died. November. 1929, the defendant began to advertise in the "North-China Daily News" that he was trading in' Chinese, Indian and American cotton goods at 49 ing Road and he was soliciting] business, therefore the plaintiff Instructed his lawyers to. take action.
The lawyers wrote to defendant! and called his attention to. the clause of the dissd tating that unless Tees: action. would be taken.
'The lawyers of the defendant wrote that he did not recognize Rosenfeld gs the owner of the Dusiness ard that there had been no. consideration for the clause in the dissolution agreement, and that it-was unreasonable and' could not be.enforeed and that they were prepared to accept, servi Mr, Victor Gensburger heard of] the dispute and set about bringing the partis to an amicable settle He first got the plaintiff, Rosen-fold, to give him authority to Bring about the settlement gensburger then had. conversations with both parties.
On January 12, 1931, Gensburger states—"In my room "(which is in the Stock Exchange) Simmons and Thad a final talk and we came definite decision, that, Simmons was to pay Rosenfeld Tls. 0,000 "in three instalments of Tls. 10,000 leach. That is Tls. 10,000 "at once Tis, 20,000 within, next 12 month Jand Tls. 10,000 in the next 12 months, that Simmons should be allowed to continue trading in Shanghai and that Rosenfeld would withdraw all Jelause in the dissolution agree- his" behalf, that Gensberger on. ment,"
Mr, Gensburger states that he then went into the Stock Exchange fand asked a Mr, David Judah to feome in. to be a witness to. the|Co., who on the same day wrote to agreement, Mr. Judah says evidence that about 11.45 a.m. on|Co., setting out the terriis January 12 he went into the room With Gensburger and found Sim. mons there. Gensburger sal twant you to bea witness of the net that the dispute between Rosenfeld and Mr. - Simmons been' settled on" the following terms." The terms already men foned were cited. And Judah goes fon to. say:—"Mr, Simmons said he fered to these terms and that Mr. Gensherger's statement was cor-reet Mr, Jadah says nothing was said by Simmons about. Rosenfeld satisfying him about his title to the business, nor mention of an indemnity sidered it a final settlement and that T was called to witness it" says Me. Judah, Gensberger then went and telephoned to Rosenfeld and told him the' settlement' to. which Rosenfeld agreed and Rosenfeld telephoned at once to. his lawyers, Messrs. White-Cooper & Ca,, who fon the same day wrote fant's lawyers setting forth—the terms of the settlement, and state Ing' that these terms were to be embodied ina short agreement between the parties.
The lawyers of, the defendant, Messrs, Teesdale & Ca, then wrote back the next day saying the terms, set out were correct but that defendant must first be sat fied that Mr. Rosenfeld was the sole owner of J. Spunt & Ca. business fand that he, Rosenfeld, wax entitled to enforce the ment and that no one else would right to any d ther that his to inspect all the documents which substantiated this.
Messrs. White-Cooper & Ca. on January 14 sent Messrs, Teesdale Ca. a copy of the assignment of the business by Betty Spunt (Mrs, Jacob Spunt) to the plaintiff, whick was certainly a document " which did substantiate the ownership of the business. Ido not know what} better document they could have sent.
The transfer of the business of J. Spunt & Ca. by "Betty Spunt, Executrix" to J. Rosenfeld had false been advertised in the "Nort China Daily News" on October 1929, The defendant also says that he was on friendly terms with Mrs. J, and Mrs, R, Spunt ard that they had told him that Mrs. J. Spunt as Jexecutrix of her husband had transferred the business to Rosenfeld. The lawyers of defendant wrote again January 22 that they were still not satisfied as to ownership fand that all negotiations must. be Jbroken off. On the same day, before] this. letter was received, the plain-lawyers had written' that though it was not part of the final' settlement, nevertheless Rosenfeld Was quite' prepared to indemnify, Simmons against any outside] claims and would like to know what further, evidence of ownership of the business was required.
'On Janéary 27 the defendant's lawyers wrote to the lawyers of the plaintiff that the terms of! their letter of January 15 (namely that their client must be satisfied that plaintiff' was the sole owner of J. Sptint & Ca, business) had
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.