Jun The facts of the Thorburn!
mystery" have now been set out considerable detail in the statement published _yesterday by the "North-China Sunday News", on the basis of information supplied by the British] Consulate here. It will be recalled that this, journal, on June 12, gave the first connected story of the disappearance of Mx. Joha Thorburn. The British authorities have gone to much trouble in sifting the evidence at their! disposal. They have also endeavoured without any apparent success to induce the local off cials at Soochow. to realize thei force of the facts ascertained jand the desirability of cooperate ing in the elucidation of the mystery of Mr, Thorburn's ats. The matter ing carried further. The} Minister has been brought into the picture; the Government at Nanking' will now have to consider how they} intend to proceed to dispose of} an incident which has, for them and for their administration Very serious implications. Sir Miles Lampson is reported to be urging that Dr. C. T. Wang should institute a commission of inquiry. It can hardly be doubted that, in view of the facts now made available, Dr. Wang will appreciate the urgency of the suggestion and proceed accordingly. Circumstantial and other evidence now shows that Mr. John Hay Thorburn, "on "the evening May'31, left home, caught the 7.30 am. train on June 1 for Henli and, apparently on foot, reached Quinsan at 11 a.m. the} same day, Two hours Jater he} continued his unexplained journey along the railway line "in. the direction of Weiting, a mile from which station at 10 pin. the same evening the shooting incident occurred, involving the wounding of three Chinese soldiers, two of whom subsequently died. On June 2 Mr. Thorburn seems to} have "been apprehergled soldiers or gendarmerie _and handed over to. the military] police at Soochow, after dete tion at Quinsan, where one story alleges he was beaten. At Soochow he was marched to the detention barracks, known as Lao Wa Tuan, and there he was in custody up to June 11.
The difficulty of establishing these facts has been enhanced by the removal of troops from So0- chow and their replacement by other units, possibly owing to the exigencies of the Communist: campaign. There has however been at work a definite attempt conceal evidence in the erasure of the words "sea scout" from the platform at Quinsan—the writing having been seen personally by Mr. A. 1. Scott but, on the occasion of his later visit, vanished. Furthermore the stories in the Chinese press of the arrest of a foreigner have been repudiated later, while other, material proofs, of Mr. Thorburn's identity. such as the photograph taken of him custody, have been spirited away, It' is obvious that versions of such an occurrence] must differ in respect of detail Nor earn it be expected that, once it became apparent that influences} eager to hush the matter up were at work, there should be no with: drawal "of admissions already made. The sudden change from 8 position, in which a wealth of evidence was forthcoming. to connect Mr. 'Thorburn with the shooting incident and arxest. to} even the shooting! was denied or put down toa bandit affray and the very' appearance of Mr. Thorburn on the Scene was. blandly disclaimed, affords ground for' the strongest conviction that Mr. Thorburn's disappearance can be and_must be explained by certain officials at Soochow or Quinean on June This incident, the circumstances of the difficulty Rngth on February 17, last—amply showed. Now, within a few miles of Nanking and Shanghai, a foreigner can be arrested—whether—legitimately in the first, instance mat-little—and, after arrest, re= moved from place to place without there being the slightest attempt made to. dispose. of hima according to the Inw either of the Chinese Government or of the Treaties governing such a man's position. Every one will recognize that, in the best administrations, mistakes must. occur; no administration deserv—ing that name can however admit. that it is unable to ascertain the true facts in such a ease as that of Mr. Thorburn. Obviously the denials with which the British authorities have been confronted' are utterly worthless. If pre= sisted in, they are insulting to the Government at Nanking, That Government will no doubt see in this affair the acid test. of the reality of the claims which they have 30 vehemently made in support of their arguments on the extraterritoriality issue. If, in such a case, where extrater= vitoviality patently exists, where the incident happens under the very nose of the Chinese Government, a foreigner can be snatched away out of cognizance of his own people and of the Govern= ment themselves, then" those arguments fall badly to the ground. So far as. can thered, definite proof that Mr. Thorburn is alive dates back so. Jong ago as June 11. In the eleven days that have elapsed knowledge that his treatment and whereabouts were in danger of. causing embarrassing inves tions has evidently spread among those who, at one time or another, had him in their power. What therefore has happened to him since then is only a matter conjecture—hopetul or other= ise. It isthe duty of the Chine ese Government to see that the conjecture, however distressing and unpalatable to. them, ie transformed into accurate know= ledge at the earliest possible date, The British Government public opinion with emphatically not accept the view that, no stich knowledge can be obtained and speedily disclosed, Visitors to Mokanshan will be interested to learn that ite Municie pal Administrative "Bureau has Brranged to collect taxes, us from Chékiane Provincial Government, 21, with the approval of, the
follows:, Twenty cents on every ticket, booked from any station to Mokanshan or vice versa; ten cents on the cost. of every sedan Jchaiv carrier from Yucheng to Mokanshan or vice versa; one dollar on every motorcar provided ty the Chekiang Highway Administration entering or leaving Mokanhan; and a similar tax on private motor ears except when empty care fave driven by non-owner.
Ax interesting visitor to Shanghay at present is a leading Chinese Mohammedan, Li, Fong-show, save. the "Sinwanpao." The visitor, whose parents and grand-parents were all Mohammedans, is now 109 ars of age, but he walks as briskly as youth, fu an. interview with experienced in unravelling. its ig] menibers of the Chinese press, he details, must gravely perturb the} stated that his wife died over 30 Government at Nanking.
It) 3¢@°8 ago, since which time he has will be expected therefore that] Tavcnce, exenncey inthe arena the conduct of a searching in- yom Honan several weeks ago wth quiry will be ordered at the] the Intention to study local condi earliest possible moment. Thel tions, He had not returned to his Government have, recently, in] home since the death of his "wife the most emphatic terms, made themselves responsible for the safety of foreigners in China4 The history of the last few months shows how inadequately they are equipped for fultlment of this obligation in. provinces beyond their immediate ken. The murders in Fukien last year of Miss Nettleton and the numerous kidnap-Pings of missionaries, some of whom are still in capt yet to meet the punish me!
Such outrages merited.
Even] nearer the Capital and in regard to a Chinese and not a forei resident, the Government ha been unable v their wishes against the arbitrat Persecution by local military officials, as the gross victim tion of Dr. Teng of Kuling—which these columns referred although he had two sons, four grandsons and four great-grandsons,
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.