Aug. 14.
Although the immediate task before Shang hai is to strain every energy toward mitigation of the asperities of the present crisis, it is important that the basic causes of the upheaval should be recognized.—Shanghal-Janders have naturally a lively desire to ensure the safety of their city." Exploitation of that desire for the purpose of establishing theories which Japanese spokesmen would like to be accepted should be critically examined, The parallel with 1032 can be too closely pressed. Conditions are not altogether the same as in that crisis of five years ago, Discerning the resentment, here at what seems to Shanghai to be an un= warrantable threat to Its peace, Japanese apologists, as can be gathered ' from Mr. Shemensu Okamoto's attitude at the abortive meeting of the Joint Commission, seck to throw the blame on the Chinese authorities. It Is contended first that, in permitting the Peace Preservation Corps, formed with Jap~ fanese approval in 1932, to develop military activities, the Chinese' have breached the agreement of that year. Those activities have included the preparation of defences. in' Chapel and other parts of Chinese territory and the reinforcement of the Corps by the despatch of regular soldiers of the seth Division which distinguished itself in 1932 in the defence of Chapel. Both sides have given assurances that they will not take the Initiative In attack, 'Those assurances are' genuine enough but fundamentally weak. 'The Japanese' contend that the approach Chinese troops so close to their lines in the Settlement may compel them to take up certain positions which may or may not involve entry into Chinese territory. The' Chinese are believed to have stated that, while they will not attack they are bound 16 resist any movement of Japanese troops into' Chinese territory. Events yesterday proved' how slender has been the safeguard thus offered.
The trouble about topographical disc sions of this kind lies in the overriding importance of the main issue between the: Chinese and Japanese Governments. A. state of "undeclared" war has been proceeding in the North since the first week in July. Pronouncements by both sides have indicated marked divergence of view. Although desperate efforts are being made to devise 9 peaceful solution, the progressive deteriora~ tion of the situation has induced both nations: to make provision against extremity, each in' its own way and according to its own conception' of its requirements, 'The Chinese Government has been reticent regarding its actual measures of defence. 'The Japanese Government has followed the same reticence but not s0 closely, for the mobilization of its reserves, the issue of flamboyant appeals to' Lits people and the thundering menaces indulged in by its military and civilian spokesmen have left no doubt in any reasonable man's mind that action is being methodically prepared to support words—and the words talk of peace only in terms of extra ordinarily oppressive demands from China. It would not be unfair to suggest that Japan' is, in fact, behaving with such minatory agavessiveness that, in spite of the lip service paid to the cause of peace, she would really be disappointed if that service by some fluke became honoured by the event, It is true, of course, that she has reason to complain of palpable dilatoriness and other irritating eva~ sions which have hampered her in a tentative approach to settlements, but she has so consistently kept the velvet glove negligently Joose on the mailed fist that it has been frequently impossible to tell where intimidation had given way to conciliation, In such circumstances is it to be wondered at that the Chinese authorities fect impelled to make some show, at any rate, of equipping their people for defence? In so doing they have no doubt anticipated rather than waited on Japanese actions, as, for example, by the steady reinforcement and arming of the Peace Preservation Corps during the past week. It is regrettable that they should have felt Impelled to take this action, for it was understood that they had definitely decided that Shanghai's embroilment should be avoided at all costs, in the interests of China, political and. economic. Yet it is Impossible to blame them exclusively for developments which have clearly derived from circumstances not under their sole control. In the light of the emotions created by the movements from Japan is It to be wondered at that the atmosphere became electrical, thus giving rise to just such an unpremeditated clash as caused the deplorable tragedy at Hungjao? Is it not: pertinent to observe how dificult it has been for the Japanese themselves to control actions taken with the avowed object of preserving military and naval enclosures from outside intrusion? On the top of all this comes the Third Japanese Fleet, slipping without notice into Shanghai's harbour with all the para:
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.