The Jewish Case To the Editor of the "Nonmi-Ciuwa Dany News"
Sin—In referring to Dr. Chaim 'Welzmann's speech, in your Jeaderette on August 6, you said there is a gulf between the' school of thought which contends that Palestine should be re~ turned to the Jews in fole irrespective of other people's interests, and. those who believe that the only real chance of a settlement is by some compronifse by which the rights of all concerned are recognized. Your theory, though fair when looked upon' from a. general standpoint of view, is not in this case supported by sound reasoning. No fair-minded or responsible Jew much less Dr. Welzmann, does harbour the thought of gaining his point at the cost of others. Even the most ardent Zionist does of wish for more than a fair chance on an equal footing with others. What, every Jew desires, lurider present conditions, is a free and unrestricted access to the Holy Land where he can work out his destiny and live in peace, Jews are not aiming at politico: control in Palestine at this juncture, even if such could be had for the ushing. They are content. to~leave this prerogative to the Mandatory Power for the time being, and until sucha time when self-government could be had to advantage; and In the absence of political control there no question of exclusive rights. There will be a chance for all to live on equal terms. 'The Jew's immediate concern ig that he be allow. ed to go about his way free and unhampered and to live as elrcum+ stances may permit, under his own municipal government as is done in 'Tel-Aviv. Such, I am sure, were the views held by' the authors of the Balfour Declaration, and such, one may fee at a glance, Is embedded in this famous" document, 'As has been already stated in your valued columns on July 30, the first ten years of British occupa tion was peaceful, and Jews and Arabs in Palestine lived quite friendly and were pleased with each other, Jews bought lands from Arab' holders at fabulous. prices, cultivated the same and made them fruitful by hard' work "ind skilled Aabour, enhancing thereby the value of Tand sult held by the Arabs This state of affairs could indefinitely had not interested individuals trigues and incited" the simple-minded Arabs against the Jews, Bat for this pernicious work, Jews and Arabs could have still "lived in amity and goodwill with each other. There was give and take on both sides, with "no question of one pushing on his way at the expense of the other, No force of any sort at any time was used, and if landowners did not wish to part with their holdings no power on earth could have made them do #0, and there matters would have ended, 'The Arabs, us a nation, have no settled home! He Is nomad by" nature, and if It sulted his purpose to sell' out his interests in one place is immaterial for him if he did fo and went to live in another, There is not, therefore, an Arab grievance in Palestine, nor have they any cause for complaint, The views held by the British Government in 1917 concerning Jewish settlement in Palestine, as under lining the Balfour Declaration, stilt hold good and are workable as far as Jews are concerned, The latter have played their part fairly and creditably to themselves, Tt is the Arabs who are wanting, and there not the shadow of a cause for complaint on their part 1 cannot fail in with your views that the Arabs have historical rights in Palestine. What historical relation they have to the place is the act of conquest, but this does not give the victor national rights. It needs the shark and stamp of the people inhabiting a land to entitle them to such a claim. What has the Arab done in Palestine; what mark has he Jett in the land to justify his claim fo historical rights? He has not a single place in the whole land which ho can, call his own in a national Sense. The very sacred places the Arabs hold are of Jewish origin and belong thereto, 'The Jews, on the other hand, even after the havoc and devastation wrought by a score of centuries still have their mark almost on every inch of the land in 'Palestine, Ruined and devastated as result of the Arabs' invasion and Ultimate capture, Palestine remained what it was then, and the captors did not inlay in li either money or thought for ils development, content= ing themselves with the bare idea of mastership. T-do not, therefore, concur that the Arabs' have any historical or national right to Palestine, nor have they any grievance against the Jews. Their hue and ery is simply the work of propaganda, Dr. Chaim Weizmann and, others were not wide of the mark in not sharing the views of those who recommend compromise and that' sort of a patch-up settlement. They are perfectly correct laying the cause of this turmoil and unrest in Palestine at the door of the Government. This is, indeed, a universal verdict, and it, was stated in your columns recently, had the authorities in Palestine used proper measures in the riot of 1929, there would have been no recurrence of the same in 1036.
As to the risk resultant from "All, om—2," I should say a people who had walted for two thousand years in the hope of one day re-Covering their independence, should prefer fo remain in that hope for another two. thousand years so. rather than barter their birthright for one-quarter share, or sell the same for a plate of pottage. Compromise may have Its value, but it will not settle things definitely. It may serve for a. while, but it is bound to leave room for {ietions and lay the seeds for further (rouble.
Dr. Weizmann may be wrong in isting on abolishing the quota, but the quota administered fairly and in the sense it was originally inten"
There were times, especially during the troublous days, when skilled labour was lamentably scarce Palestine, and lands were left undeveloped for the want of labour, but instead of relaxing the quota and releasing more men into the country, the Government used more drastic restrictions In deference to the Arabs' wishes and threat, Whitehall would have done well had it played its hand impartially and not minding either side. By using the power invested In her, as 2 Mandatory Power, Great Britain Could have played her game to the satisfaction of both, Arabs and Jews.
But she did not, she has fitted with the aggressor and unwittingly brought conditions in Palestine to a climax. ing and being left with nothing." A Strip of land that can hardly" hold one-tenth of the population of a race will not give them the much desired national home, It is preposterous that a Power like Great" Britain should not have been able to carry out an undertaking she has solemnly sponsored; an undertake endorsed and gus Fepresentatives of fifty-two countries. Britain has simply given in at the Instance of a people who have no touch of humour nor a sense of proportion.
You hit a right note in saying, "without the backing of some strong er, the Jews in Palestine would In a perilous condition." It is too true, even in the ease of world Jewry. It is backing that they need, as th Arabs seem to have, and this is the crux of the whole difficulty. In this instance, however, the Jews thought they did have some powerful backing Uehind them. They trusted to the weatest power on earth—Great Britain—and taking her word as final, migrated Into Palestine as best they' could, and now they are at the risk of being deserted.
It appears, although the Jews have suffered for so long, the eid of their offering Is not yet in view. They will have to suffer more, 1 suppose. There is an old saying, "He that is drenched in water, neod not mind even the heaviest of showers."
Jewish urgent needs in Palestine may be summarized as follows:
A Frée_and unrestricted admission, regulated by' the number the coun:
fry can absorb from time to time.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.