The Archive · 1932

MERE RUMOURS

Sept. 20, Except that speculation on the contents of the Lytton Report is, decerning more rife thi when this journal issued first warning against the danger of the practice, no further reference would be made to it, but the telegram from Nanking, publish-led elsewhere on this very subject Jseems to emphasize the need for la further reminder that specul: tion is not only unwise, but may in certain circumstances prove of very great danger to the peace of this: part of the world. Unfe: tunately, it has been necess) for these rumours to be publish led, not only because they are Mews of themselves, but also because they serve to give readers a very clear idea of the hopes that both sides to the present unhappy dispute are pinning on the results of the Commission's labours. It needs to be driven home with all the force possible that, except the actual writers of the Lytton. Report, in fact the Commission itself, and certain of their confidential officers, no one knows what has been written. Neither the Chinese nor the Japanese governments are acquainted: the findings of fact nor the ce: delusions which the Commission has drawn therefrom, and any [claim to the contrary must be regarded not only as. idle but "subversive of the best inter: lof all concerned. At the mos these speculators know what they would have found had they been members of the Commission themselves. This knowledge they fave endeavoured to bolster up lat the most, if not _positiv ly ignorant—of the very careful statements made by Lord Lytton end other members of the Commission to insistent newspaper men, statements which cannot, leven by the most exten: stretching be considered to [convey one iota of information.

It is for these reasons that be a ccnriderable feeling of suspense' Jamongst the Chinese, If recent orderliness is founded on hopes of 4 completely favourable juds-iment it is in some respects t" be regretted, for if the ultimate findings are not entirely favour of China, there is likely to he a revulsion of feeling more serious than an outbreak would have been on Sunday last. It is towards the prevention jan unfortunate event thi Chinese press which has render Jed excellent service to the 0vminent during these last few weeks, could do something even more valuable. It is becoming increasingly "necessary that where speculations as) to contents of the eagerly awaited report are published that due emphasis should be laid on the: fact that they are founded on no basis of fact, and in many merely dictated by a wish th: father to the thought. Po: if that la thrust home sufficiently: tapen readers of Chinese nows-papers the depression conseque' upon an unfavourable report. indeed it be unfavourable, and at ithe present moment there is not the slightest evidence either wav—may to a very large extent be Jobviated and the present gout conditions continue But if Chinese opinion is to be encouraged in the belief that their report Lord Lytton and hi colleagues do not compro larly of the essential principles which form the basis of the Chinese contention there may be grave danger of disappointment, [There is not the slightest ground for suggesting that the report definitely upholds China's sover-feign authority over Manchuria in name as well as fact, nor for the lather rumour that demilitaris tion of Manchuria will commended, with the doing away lof Chinese troops and Japa.iese military forces there. At the most. there is amongst certain [Chinese a hope that the Commission will make recommendations to that effect. On the Japanese side there appears to be equal confidence that certain of the findings will be favourable to them. The facts as they are generally known to the public at. large, and even its better inform ed sections, might support the hopes of either side but the Lytton Commission, it is to be hoped, has been in possession of evidence much more complete, much more cogent, and much quality of legal evidence. If this be so, speculation which is obviously based on less informa~ tion than is in the possession of the Commission may be far wide of the actual realities, and no service is fendered present order, for the possibility of future pence imaginings which, having all ithe circumstances in mind, mus' be, to say the least, vain. Th purveyors of speculation simply not know, and those wha trust in them are bound for tht ditch into which blindness so often lands the ignorant.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account