The Archive · 1933

W. Amery and Sir Naime

'Stewart "Sandernan which reflect-led the views of extreme opponents lof the League were included. this moment wher Japan's withdrawal, 30 long expected, is now an accomplished fact' it is peculiarly appropriate to examine the course of this debate. The ultimate effect of the withdrawal feannot possibly" be judged "now. Exaggeration of its dangers is to be ere should equally be no disposition to dismiss it lightly, Mr. Amery' and, in a minor degree, Sir Nairne Stewart Bangeman were lone voices erying" in the wilderness. Will history in the long run judge them right? It is apparent that the present House of Commons does not think 30. Critics who maintain that the so-called intervention of the League in a dispute between two oriental countries hax greatly prejudiced the peace of the Far Bast and Drevented an carly stabilisation of the situation can be met by the retort that the League, on reference by one of its member-states, had no other choice. That ix not a complete answer for, even then, it might have been possible for the League to. have once perceived the established ascendancy of the militarist party in Japan, the consequent development of a policy' Virtual annexation of Manchuria! and the inability of other nations, even in solid compact, to withstand—that—development. Endowed with this perception the League might have frankly: told China that the dispute must be regarded ax purely local and the outcome of locsel differences to be settled direct fietween the two purties, with, perhaps, the pos:

ble reservation that the "good: offices"" of the Powers could be:

Wwoked by mutual consent.

Putting oxide the question would then'

n able successfully to re-jure to do its be seen that the majority of the speakers in the House of Commons on both sides of the Speaker's Chair, insisted that somethings far transcending the merits or demerits e€ Japan's case or China's plight was at stake. It wax not less than the very foundations of the League itself, "point which Lord Lytton made long azo when he asserted that if Jabin found Manchuria to be her life-line, the world looked upon the League in the same usent, Si ne Stewart Sandeman We are all getting ther tired of the League of ations' and therein epitomized feeling which has unmistakably ined sgrouncl. The symptoms are not only in Japan. They to be found in Europe and in South America. They are and e been aggravated by the economic malaise and, in no small degree. by the atmosphere of Dunditdom generated at Gene: Impatient idealism is not always, in its efforts to proselytise. Tt is apt to forget that it draws, strength from elements which, n essence, are subversive of the principles of international amity. It therefore incites opposition even from those who at one time were the disciples of the League—like Mr. Amery himself—and, Perhaps, fought to bring it into existence. The course of world events has taken nations far from the spirit of Lncarno, in which the League's first assertion of its moral ascendancy stood clear. The League has been' shaken by this renunciation of Japan. The anti of Commons. was in a measure accentuated by realisation of the obligations still resting on member-states in respect of the Bino-Japanese dispute. The question for the future seems to be when ther the fabric of the League will be firm enough to bear fulfilment of those obligations in the light be of the clear determination of the principal Governments to keep Out of warlike entanglements. That is where opponents of the League have their strongest argiment. And it is not enough to say that Japanese obduracy is forcing the pace.

The speeches in the House of] Commons with their fervent! constancy to the. League give material for reassurance. It is unfortunate that membership of the League is. now regarded as an international hobby foisted upon individual nations by dogmatic theorists. Memories, are short: otherwise it would be recognised that the nations; themselves created the League and the League stands or falls by their own contribution to it, This is the comment made by Sir George Gillett, formerly Labour Minister of Transport, on Mr. Amery's speech:

"....he (Mr. Amery) has voiced the "Views of 1 certain number of] men. and women whom one meets in daily life and who go about saying, as the right hon. Gentleman practically "said, that the days of the League of Nations! are more or less numbered... 4 not look upon' the right hon.! Gentleman asa realist; 1, look'

him as a pessimist: expresses.. one said to me lat is really the view that he

the other "day "Dog. tas eaten dog. We have we will) always have Sir George cannot be accused blinking the facts, He proceeded to assert that the possibility, p of the League confronting such an emergency as that under re-jew had always been in the: minds of—observers—a badly governed and disorganised county at issue with a militarily efficient country desirous of expansion. He noted that the consequent difficulties had evoked the ery that the League was no tuse and he added "But if a system of warfare has been xoing for thousands of years and if we are attempting by' means of the League, to. begin to mould another system in which war will be replaced ultimately'

then "merely because} ely twenty years the:

system is still inn perfect, are we to say that the whole well be Labour view had already been endorsed by Major J. W. Hills, 4 former holder of office and" a Conservative beyond suspicion:

"I prefer to err with 42 countries supporting what my right hon, Friend (ate, Amery) calls nonsense' than with right hon, Friend's friends, even. plus Siam.

And Major Hills ironically confessed to being "one of those conscious or unconscious hypo-cutes who, believe in the League of Nations." To sum up: the debate showed unanimous resistance to the idea of any armed intervention or action calculated, to involve Great Britain in wi it also showed a sreneral com tion that the Government's support of the League was sound. It faced the complexity of the situation created by China's weak. ness and Japan's loss of faith in|be the Principles of the Covenant. Above all it indicated a realisation of the need for the League to retain its vigilance on the course of evens and on the due implications of its responsibilities for the mission entrusted to it. Foreign policy, as Sir John Simon was careful to point out, ut the end, may seem slow. The temper of the debte showed that few on either side of the House disputed the wisdom of that attitude.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account