The Archive · 1938

Other Doctors Consulted

Mr. Thesiger: When she had fully recovered what happened about the morphia?—For a time she was definitely better and I tried to see whether I could get her off the morphia by graduated reduction, and up to a point I was successful, but when we tried to get it below two or three grains daily all the old symptoms and difficulties returned.

Was it about then that Dr. McKeag saw her in consultation with you?—I asked Dr. McKeag to see her because this was a serious responsibility, but he agreed that in view of the long history the only thing to do was to accept addiction and try so far as possible to control it.

Dr. Gordon said that about the end of 1933 or beginning of 1934 she became pregnant, and Mr, Mitchell was called in.

Mr. Thesiger: And in view of her condition of health did the question arise as to the possibility of letting the—pregnancy continue?—Very seriously.

What happened?—We discussed the matter, and I happened to be a member of the committee at the time sitting on the question of abortion, and I reported this case to the whole committee composed of distinguished gynæcologists. There was a great deal of argument and no conclusion was come to.

"The patient herself," Dr, Gordon added, "was very anxious to go on with the pregnancy, and Dr. Mitchell agreed that the responsibility of allowing her to continue might be taken, provided she agreed to have a Cæsarian section done when the time This proviso was on two grounds, one being that it was doubtful if a natural birth could take place, and the other that in a morphia addict there was no margin for counteracting shock should labour be prolonged or serious abnormality be encountered.

"We also very strongly advised sterilization, as we did not think that a second delivery was likely to be possible without fatal issue, and that even early interference might be attended with very serious risks," added Dr. Gordon.

Mr. Thesiger: I think the original letter you got from the doctor who sent her to you dealt with sexual matters?—It did.

Dr. Gordon said that he called in Dr. McKeag and the position was explained to Miss Ruddle, who agreed to the medical proposals.

Until a month before her confinement was due Miss Ruddle was wonderfully well and in a much easier state of mentality than at any other time, and the morphia was reduced again quite considerably. Shortly before her confinement li was necessary to increase the morphia.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account