Judgment was given on Dec. 20 in the Court of Appeal (Lords Justices Greer, Slesser, and Scott) on the appeal and cross-appeal in the action by Baron Victor de Stempel, of Hallam Street, London, against his wife's stepfather, Mr. Walter Dunkels, a diamond broker, of Devonshire Street, London. The action was heard by the late Mr. Justice Swift and a special Kings Bench jury, states the "Manchester Guardian.
A cross-appeal by Mr. Dunkels against an award of £6,000 to the Baron on the claim that Mr. Dun-kols had procured his dismissal was dismissed by a majority verdict of the Appeal Court.
The jury had also assessed at £200 the damages which the Baron claimed for alleged slander, but Mr. Justice Swift held that the words complained of as slanderous were not actionable. The Baron appealed against this finding and his appeal on one count was allowed, damages being assessed at £100.
Lord Justice Greer, in a judgment which Lord Justice Slesser read, said that in regard to the alleged slanders the question for the Court was when ther the late Mr. Justice Swift was right in holding that the words which the jury found were defamatory were nor actionable. In his (Lord Justice Greers) view that decision was wrong, as the evidence showed that the words were spoken in relation to Baron de Stempel's occupation.
While there was no doubt about Mr. Walter Dunkels's good offices in helping the Baron to obtain employment, he (the Lord Justice) thought that the Observation of Mr. Justice Swift—that Mr. Dunkels seemed to have conceived a dislike for his son-in-law which ultimately developed into bitter hatred—was justified by the evidence. In Lord Justice Greer's view, the words "Victor is a Jew-hater" were defamatory of Baron de Stempel in relation to his business.
Regarding a second alleged slander, the other members of the Court, he said, held the view that the words were not capable of a defamatory meaning, and while he had doubt about the matter he did not think it right to differ from them.
In regard to the cross-appeal against the £6,000 damages, Lord Justice Greer said in his opinion there was evidence on which the jury could properly find that Mr. Walier Dunkels had procured the dismissal of the Baron from his employment. In the result the Baron's appeal on the slander issue should be allowed and the cross-appeal dismissed.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.