The Archive · 1938

Dissenting Judgment

Lord Justice' Slesser, in a dissenting judgment, said that in regard to the words "Victor is a Jew hater" (used by Mr. Walter Dunkels about the Baron), to say that a man was possessed of hatred was, in'his opinion, likely to tend to lower him in the estimation of right-thinking members of society generally. That it would be fatal disqualification in a trade largely with and dependent upon Jews to be known as a Jew hater was scarcely disputed.

He thought there was evidence on which a jury might properly find, as they must be taken to have done in this case, that they were necessarily spoken to Mr. Otto Dunkels (defendant's cousin, who employed the Baron) in order to effect the Baron's dismissal in relation to the Baron's trade, and were not merely to be taken as calculated to affect him adversely therein. He (the Lord Justice) agreed that, as to the damages attributable to this slander, this part of the Baron's appeal succeeded.

As to the second slander, suggesting that Mr. Otto Dunkels could "kick the Baron out as he was worth no more than a clerk receiving less than £500 a year," Lord Justice Slesser agreed that the words were incapable of a defamatory meaning.

With reference to the cross-appeal by Mr. Walter Dunkels relating to the judgment for £6,000 in favour of the Baron, Lord Justice Slesser thought the jury was fully entitled to come to the conclusion that the Baron had entered into an agreement to continue in the service of Mr. Otto Dunkels until reasonable notice had been given or, alternatively, that the agreement was to continue during the currency of Mr. Otto Dunkels's business as long as the Baron was ready and willing to carry out his part of the contract. On that the question arose whether Mr. Walter Dunkels did procure the Baron's dismissal by Mr. Otto Dunkels. It was true that, from August, 1933, onwards, Mr. Walter Dunkels had been putting pressure on Otto to turn the Baron out of his business. But that was nothing to the point unless the Baron could prove that the procurement of his dismissal was effected through Mr. Louis Oppenheimer, of the Diamond Corporation, by procure ing Mr. Oppenheimer to tell Mr. Otto Dunkels that the Baron was not to to the offices of the corporation again until the Baron and his wife had settled their differences.

The jury were entitled to think that in effect Mr. Louis Oppenheimer did tell Mr. Otto Dunkels that the Baron should not come to the offices. The real difficulty in the Baron's way was 10 show that Mr. Walter Dunkels ever communicated with Mr. Louis Oppenhelmer on the subject at all. Here conjecture would not suffice.

Lord Justice Slesser thought that there was no evidence in the case on which the jury could properly come to the conclusion that Mr. Walter Dunkels had procured Mr. Louis Op—penheimer to tell Mr. Otto Dunkels that the Baron must not go to the offices of the Diamond Corporation, and therefore no evidence that Mr. Walter Dunkels procured the Baron's dismissal. That dismissal appeared to have been caused, on the Baron's own admission, by his refusal to give Mr. Otto Dunkels a statement for the consideration of Mr. Louis Oppenheimer.

In the opinion of Lord Justice Slesser the cross-appeal should succeed.

Lord Justice Scott agreed with the judgment of Lord Justice Greer, and Observed that to say "Victor is a Jewhater" was obviously defamatory as it suggested a warped character. He agreed with Lord Justice Slesser that the words in the second slander were not capable of being defamatory and therefore the question of their being actionable did not arise.

Leave to appeal to the House of Lords was granted.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account