The Archive · 1938

Woman Who Gave

GAS TO STEPSON

Judge Binds Widow Over in Tragic Case It is obvious that what you did was the result of a complete breakdown of your health, and while you were ina sad condition of overstrain, These words were addressed by Mr. Justice Goddard to a tall, refined-looking woman, who listened with bowed head at the Old B. states the "News of the World She is Mrs. Elspeth Grant Phillips, 55, of Rutland-gate, Hyde Park, S.W. widow of Lieut-Colonel Thomas Brocklehurst Phillips, late of the 13th Hussars, In a very distressing case she pleaded guilty to administering coal-gas to her mentally deficient stepson. Charles Douglas Phillips. axed 35.

ith intent to murder him. and to tempted suicide.

Mr. G. B. McCiure, prosecuting. stated that Mrs. Phillips, a woman of means and position. lost her hu band on November 28, and at the lime of these happenings was undergoing very great mental and physical strain Dr. Matheson, governor and medical officer of Holloway Prison, told of examining Mrs. Phillips that morning and finding her greatly improved.

He added he thought she was now quite safe.

Dr. Annis Gillie, who attended Mrs, Phillips and. her husband, expressed a similar opinion.

Judge: Is the stepson now living with Mrs. Phillips?—Mr. Norman Birkett, K.C., defending: Yes.

Judge: He is mentally defective in certain directions?

Mr. Birkett: Yes.

Tt is a case of arrested development.

Dr. Gillie stated Mrs. Phillips was intensely devoted to Douglas, and he was equally devoted to her.

Mr. Birkett urged it would be cruel to separate the widow and her stepson, as the happiness of Douglas depended on the oversight and care which his stepmother alone could give him.

Mrs. Phillips was bound over for two years,

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account