The Archive · 1938

Captains of Their Souls

Recent developments in Hankow should give the Japanese furiously to think, for the appointment of Generalissimo Chiang Kaishek as virtually dictator of China, amounts to an endorsement of his policy by the Kuomintang. The General Executive of the Party has in fact passed a vote of confidence in its leader, and that despite the defeats which the Japanese have up to the present been able to inflict upon the Chinese armies in the field. The Kuomintang Congress has elevated the Generalissimo to a position only held before by Sun Yat-sen, and because of that fact has done him an unparalleled honour. While, on the face of it, it would seem that powers of a dictator have been conferred upon him it is clear that there are certain limitations the most important of which concerns the Party's decision to adhere io the principles of the San Min Chu Yi, thereby making it quite clear that there is no possibility of the Communists ever being allowed to dominate the Government. That is the claim which is made, though historians will realize that this is rather the declaration of a pious wish regarding the future than an exclusion of possibilities, It is always possible that Communism might grow to such an extent in China that the Kuomintang might be ousted from power, and the resolution governing that point merely emphasized that, as long as the Kuomintang is in control, the Communist party in China will nave to accept a back seat in the government of the country. That Japan by her action is driving the Chinese nation into the arms of Bolshevism is only too plain, and if it succeeds in bringing about the downfall of the Kuomintang there is more than a grave danger that those political sentiments which are anathema to the Japanese will obtain a greater hold upon the country than they have at present. This is a very obvious fact, and the existence of the Kuomintang is the only real guarantee that all that large portion of China, which has not yet and may never fall into the hands of Japan, will not one day become communist through the desperation which the Japanese campaigns are engendering. At the moment that desperation is directed towards the successful conclusion of present hostilities, but ultimate defeat may very well mean that China would turn to communism.

It is one of the contrarieties of the whole situation that Japan claims to be fighting what she may actually bring about, and the position is that she can only prevent it by the total subjugation of China a task which it is believed is entirely beyond Japan's ability. There is every reason to believe that even now the Japanese have bitten off more than they can conveniently masticate, and the more they extend their gains the more difficult will become their situation. Chiang Kai-shek, having in his hands the whole conduct of the war and the government, has achieved a unity of control which does in fact amount to a dictatorship. Perhaps not so much from the positive point of view as from the negative. Thus while he is only empowered to request the Kuomintang Congress to reconsider its decisions, he is given the final say in regard to resolutions passed by the Central Executive Committee of the Kuomintang; he is given the power to veto them, should he think it necessary in the interests of the country. From that point of view it would seem that his dictatorship is not one of initiative as other dictatorships have shown themselves to be, but merely one of restraint, His power is not so absolute, though he can, should he so desire to prevent the enactment of any resolutions likely in his opinion to interfere with the determined opposition which China is offering to the Japanese invasion. The manifesto which has been issued by the Sixth National Kuomintang Congress, the instrument which confers this new role on Chiang Kai-shek is in itself an important and interesting document. The hope is expressed that Japan will abandon her policy of aggression and ce-operate with China. That is what Japan says she is trying to do, though it is apparent that she wants China to ce-operate with her, and not she with China. To some there may be little difference between the two points of view, though on little reflection it is plain that she intends to play the dominant role in this Far Eastern partnership which she is seeking to set up. The declaration of the Congress scrupulously to respect all treaties designed for the maintenance of international peace to which she is a party, would have read somewhat better had it been applied'tto all treaties to which China is pledged, for treaty infractions in the past are to a very great extent responsible for the predicament in which she finds herself to-day.

The resume of the manifesto which appears in another column indicates a praiseworthy sanity of outlook. The people are warned not to entertain false hopes nor to expect miraculous happenings. They are told net to count on foreign assistance, but to depend upon their own efforts in their endeavour to beat their enemy. There are indications that the Congress contemplates the further mobilization of the nation for the purpose of continuing its struggle, and throughout it all, and especially in view of the inferences to be drawn from the document, there is to be found no sign of weakening confidence in the future, but the reaffirmation' of a quiet, realistic determination to defend the country against the aggression to which it is being subjected. What does all this mean? It means that, despite the huge slaughter of the past eight months, the destitution of millions of refugees fleeing before the Japanese forces, and the continual bombing of towns and cities, the morale of the nation has not been shattered. That that is the finding of the Kuomintang Congress is apparent from its decisions, The Japanese armies may have made great material progress in China with their better training and equipment, but their successes have had no spiritual effect upon either the Chinese people or their government. That has to be remembered. The belief that some people held that the end of the hostilities would be brought about by the collapse of Chiang Kai-shek's government may still prove ultimately to be true, but for the moment the Party's faith in the Generalissimo has again been demonstrated, and he is firmer in the saddle now than he has ever been before. The stubbornness with which the Chinese forces are resisting the Japanese along the Yellow River and around Hsuchowfu is reflected in the attitude of the Kuomintang. That attitude will, at any rate for the present, be maintained; the nation is re-pledged ta a policy of victory through suffering, the capacity of the Chinese for which is being shown to be as great now as it has been in the past. China may not eventually emerge victorious from this struggle, but she is determined to make Japanese success so castly that it may prove to be like Dead Sea fruit, very bitter in the mouth, The Newer Strategy What In Parenthesis prophesied early in the hostilities would occur has apparently happened, for Reuter reports from Hankow that on the northern Tsinpu Front the fighting has developed into a sort of crazy patchwork, with large forces of each side operating behind the front lines of the other, while various units are reported to be completely cut off from the rest of their armies. It will be remembered that In Parenthesis, commenting on some of the communiques issued by both sides, consistently claiming advances, remarked that if this continued the contenders would pass through each other's lines and be facing back to back. Of course it was merely a light-hearted jape, and it was not thought for one moment that the various commanders would take the hint seriously, which goes to show that there are stranger things in this world than it wots of in all its philosophy On the other hand it is all on a par with much of the rest of what is happening. Japan is bus; beating China to her knees out of a deep-rooted affection for the Chinese, who if they knew the lag would probably remark: "No doubt it is wise to dissemble your love, but why do you kick me down stairs?" or at least something to that effect. China is being driven towards communism to save it from that dire political doctrine. Yet another singular military feat is recorded on the part of the Chinese who are reported in two instances to have surrounded bodies of Japanese troops on three sides, It would not be difficult to compile a long list of such contrarieties, but all to no purpose, for it is of no avail at this juncture to seek to impress upon the parties concerned how much better off they would be if they would only remain at peace with one another. It is to be hoped that the contending armies will discover another novel piece of stra for if they could only realise the benefits to the world at large, they would indulge in a simultaneous retreat, peace would be brought about and the writers of military text books would have new developments on which to ponder.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account