The Archive · 1936

GUIDANCE WANTED

May 13.

In discussing the salary bill of the Shanghai Municipal Council this Journal has sounded a warning against neglect of certain fundasible for the drafting of the report), Mr. H. 'Tiefenbacher, Mr. Ranald 1G, MeDonald, Mr. C. L. Seitz, Mr.'

R. Davey and Mr. G. L. Wilson were ce-opted. Its survey of the whole question is extraordinarily Jcomprehensive and affords a valu able guide to present-day issues. Yet it could not cover the details of the administration, and a Salaries Commission under the chairmanship of Mr. V. Meyer was appointed in May, 1929 as the direct outcome of its recommenda-

On the Salaries Commission, in [addition to Mr. Meyer, Mr. C. M. essential to the maintenance of a Burnie, Mr. A. C. Clear, Mr. P. mental principles which are satisfactory public service. It has Hopkins, Mz. W. P. Lambe and Mr. [P, W. Massey sat. Mr. Burnie, Mr. adduced information to show that, in comparison with records of other cities, Shanghai does not pay an' excessive figure for the Council's administration of the Settlement. 'This position is affirmed, if only' because the extravagant language used by some would-be critics does small credit to Shanghai's sense of decency and proportion; _unless steps were taken to indicate the irresponsibility of that kind of criticism gross injustice would be done to a worthy body of public servants and, moreover, the Council might find its recruitment activities seriously prejudiced. Those who} have had experience of the work of engaging men for public services Know how, almost magically, unfavourable' conditions of service—such as risks of political variations of terms of contract, lack of fidelity fulfilling obligations—seem to be communicated to the sources from which candidates have hitherto come, The result is that the employing authority has either to be content with Inferior material or th offer additional inducements which, of course, enhance the scales! of salary, This is not speculative theory. it is the plain record of actual happenings. 'The Council has to proceed with strict regard to its legal obligations, as defined in its employment contracts, otherwise its reputation suffers and, incidentally, it is lable to' be involved in expense which would rot benefit the cause of economy. More than one municipal body in Great Britain has had this painful experienee—It occurred to the Lon don County Council early in the present century—when a political mandate for retrenchment has been too precipitately acted upon in prescribing modifications in con~ ditions of service after a successful election.

These considerations do not, however, affect well argued proposals for economical administration. Indeed there is much to be said for Mr. P. H, Prevot's suggestion that the Council should institute in" quiry into the general question of] Lits public services, just as {t has; recently appointed' a committee to} report specifically on the work of tone department and acted upon' that report. At the same thine it may be convenient to recall the fact that already much material is available to Members of the Council for examination of the subject without necessarily going to the expense of setting up another commission. In 1921 a Salaries Commission made important recom~ mendations regarding terms of} salary and methods of promotion. In view of the difference between economic conditions of that period and to-day, quotation of the figures would serve no useful purpose but it might be noted that the Commission considered the Council's seals for its heads of denartremuneration to compare of unfavourably with positions of]

responsibility in other con~ cerns." That was at the beginning! fof Shanghai's "boom period" of ex: pansion, Eight years later, an Economy—Committee under different conditions. Appointed in July 1927 with wide: terms of reference, it originally had Mr. Stirling Fessenden. as the jelected Chairman and Brig.-Gen, Macnaghten as Vice-Chairman, their colleagues being Mr. B. D. F. Beith, Mr. R. Calder Marshall, Mr. K. Fukushima, Mr. N.S. Marshall, Mr. N. L. Sparke Changes in personnel ing the 19 months of the Committee's existence: Mr. N. S. Marshal resigned almost immediately: Fessenden became an_ official General Macnaghten resigned after four months, and Mr. N. L. Sparke after seven' months. At various dates Mr. V. Meyer (who. became Chairman and was largely respon-

Hopkins and Mr. Lambe could not serve after the first preliminary meeting. Their places were taken by Mr. C, Burgess, Mr. R. J. Corbett and Mr. S. L. Hsu. Briefly, this Commission overhauled the whole of the Council's methods of recruit ment, conditions of appointment, and the like. It Laid down im~ portant principles, many of them having a special relation to economy in respect of the actual terms applied to the various grades in the service and the possibility of in-Jereased reliance on locally-engaged talent. The Council, no doubt, has acted' on the proposals of these successively appointed committees, but as, in 1929 at all events, the subject seems to have been studied with special reference to. the Increase in the cost of living, economy did not receive exclusive jeonsideration. On that ground it might be appropriate if Members of the present Council, in their desire to tok: note of recent expressions. of public opinion, as, for example, Mr. C. L. Boynton "at the last Ratepayers' meeting and in correspondence published in these columns, called for a report on the subject. The Controller has already {intimated that, with the ce-operation of Heads of Departments, sweeping. measures of retrenchment have been effected. The Council might satisfy the Ratepayers by some: explicit statement on that point, at: the same time indicating how far it [has been able to act on the reports of the Economy Committes and) Salaries Commission of 1929. It should not neglect the cantinal principle of maintaining a contented and efficient public service. For that reason recruitment from overseas, to certain posts demanding special qualifications is an essential fac-for in its staffing arrangements. Nevertheless in view of the press ing requirements of the current financial position, ft is desirable that precise definitions of policy should be attempted. Specific points on which uneasiness has been. shown are the character of certain awanees, the manner in which special appointments have been. made without recourse to public advertisement, the success achieved in reducing engagements of imported personnel by resorting to the re~ cruitment of local material. Furthermore it is suggested that the con ditions governing the participation of council's employees in other} occupations require examination. The Council has no doubt borne these matters in mind, but some statement on the subject is due to the Ratepayers as the result of prevailing economic conditions and the trend of public comment.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account