Last week the "Shanghai Evening Post Mercury" published a translation of an article appearing in the "Shanghai Mainichi" severely attacking the promotion of two sons of retiring senior police officials. The Japanese journal alleged in the case of Mr. H, E. Aiers, senior assistant in the Shanghai Municipal Police, that at the age of 24 years, this young man whom the journal averred had received an education not beyond high school level, had been promoted to Chief Assistant drawing a salary rising from $750 to a maximum of $1,200, The Japanese journal according to the translation actually said that Mr. Aiers salary had been raised from $750 to $1,200 per mensem though the articles apparently includes the former variation as well. It is argued that the young man was in receipt of remuneration "much more than high Japanese officials of the Shanghai Municipal Police are getting after 20 to 30 years of service with the force." It is further alleged that Mr. Aiers only joined the force in 1934, and has consequently only about four years service to his credit. With regard to Mr. J. E. Fairbairn, alleged to be a graduate of a high school, 23 years of age and with three years service with the Police Force, it was stated that he had been promoted to senior assistant receiving $600 a month with the possibility of rising to $920.
The Japanese journal then proceeds to draw comparisons between these salaries and those of the men engaged in other branches of the service and makes the acid comment to the effect that the time has come to realize that the Shanghai Municipal Council is not the East India Company, but a municipal adminis. tration set up by people of various national ties residing in the Settlement. The paper suggests that because these young officials are the sons of their fathers their promotion has been altogether too rapid and suggests that if the system of "handing down jobs to one's sons" is continued the rights of the taxpayers will gq on being trampled underfoot.
If the facts were as the Japanese journals suggests, the matter would indeed be a serious one, but investigations made by this journal indicates a very different state of affairs, Mr. Aiers is not 2 young man of 24; he 29 years of age. He is not dra ing a salary of $1,200, but only $750. It will take 15 years for him to reach the maximum of $1,200 a month. While Mr.
Aiers may have been attached to the police for only a period of three years, he has seen much longer service with the Municipal Council, and the case as now presented is certainly not one of unprecedently rapid promotion within the short period between 1934 and now. Mr. Fairbairn, is younger, it is true, but he draws only $400 per mensem.
The fathers of neither of these two men had anything to do with the promotion which they have received. Under the system which prevails in the Municipal Service, it would be impossible for them to do so. The young men would naturally in the course of their employment be the subject of reports from their superiors to the Staff Committee. That body would scrutinize all recommendations made, and in turn make their recommendations to the Council The Japanese have representation on both the Staff Committee and the Council, and it was open to them on at least two occasions to oppose what it was proposed to do had there been any real ground for doing so. This journal has been unable to discover that at any time opposition, or protest was lodged by the Japanese representatives either on the Staff Committee or in the Council itself, and it is reasonable to assume that what was done was done perfectly openly, and with the knowledge of the representatives of all nationalities which go to constitute the Council. It is apparent that these suggestions of nepotism, or of any other kind of jiggety-poker, must of necessity fall to the ground, as, in the circumstances, completely ridiculous and without any basis in fact. Furthermore it would be the complete negation of reasonableness to adopt the policy that because a young man had a parent in the municipal service, he should be debarred from employment therein.
Now that the matter has been presented in its true light, some reference may with justice be made to the attitude of the Council in the matter. When the article first appeared in the evening contemporary, this journal approached no less than three high officials of the Municipal Council for a statement without any satisfactory result, It appeared from the replies given to a representative of this journal that the official policy was to ignore the whole thing, if not to treat it with contempt. That this journal contends was a mistaken policy. An untruthful statement reflecting upon the system of promotion in the municipal service, suggesting even that, in these two instances, nepotism had been indulged in, had been given wide publicity, and the untruth has as a result been allowed to remain current, without any attempt at official denial for an undue number of days. At any time it is practically impossible to overtake a lie, but, when it is given a running start of about five days, the task of refuting it becomes all the more difficult. In times such as these, and particularly when it is the avowed intention of the Japanese to take a greater part in the administration of the International Settlement it is imperative that attacks made upon the management of the municipal service, particularly when it is so grievous an attack as this, should be promptly and effectively dealt with. Silence on such occasions gives the impression that there may be something wrong after all, that something has been done which the Council cannot defend, and assists the attackers in their attempts, permitting the implication, by official reticence, that there is never smoke without fire. There is no substance to the allegations of the "Shanghai Mainichi" and the correct official procedure should have been to make that fact known as soon as possible. No Criticism whatever is levelled against the evening contemporary for publishing the translation which it did. That such an attack had been made was news, and important news at that. On the other hand the fact that the allegations were untrue was news which in the interests of the Council should have been immediately published, in order that the confidence ofthe ratepayers in the municipal service should not be diminished. In recent months the behaviour of the Council with regard to publicity has not been entirely satisfactory, but adherence to its policy of reticence, when under attacks of this nature, cannot be considered as anything but completely ostrich-like.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.