The Archive · 1940

The Asama Maru Case

While Tokyo awaits a reply from London to the protest regarding the removal of Germans of military age from the steamer Asama Maru, the atmosphere is made all the tenser by the anti-British demonstrations which are reported from Japan. Yet despite all the clamour and excitement, the issue raised by British action is perfectly simple, and one which should most certainly not have given rise to the present excitement. It has been made quite clear that the Japanese Government was informed of the action which it was proposed to take with regard to the men travelling in the Japanese vessel. The Asama Maru was stopped in accordance with the precepts of international law, the men of military age removed, and the ship permitted to go on her way without further interference. There is not the slightest suggestion that the -British Navy did mot carry out its duty with the utmost courtesy. it was doing something in the exercise of belligerent rights which is not only recognized as perfectly lawful, but something which has actually been done by Germany in the course of present hostilities without complaint by Great Britain, or the government of the neutral vessel then involved. In this last instance the Swedish vessel Kronprinsessan Margareta was stopped within sight of Sweden, and British fishermen removed by a German war vessel. In the case of the Asama Maru a group of Germans some of whom came within the terms of the German conscription law were proceeding to Germany via Siberia for the purpose of joining the fighting forces of their country. The very fact of universal conscription in Germany makes all men of military age soldiers, and the fact that these men were proceeding to their homeland for the purpose of doing their duty makes them just as much soldiers as if.they had been travelling in uniform as a small military unit. It is a matter of plain common sense that, if it is perfectly correct in a blockade to endeavour to prevent war supplies reaching the enemy, it is equally proper to seek to prevent reinforcements doing the same thing. Men are just as much contraband of war in the circumstances as those materials which might be used in the manufacture of munitions.

While it is difficult to cite cases quite on all fours with that of the Asama Maru, there have been enough precedents set to establish the general principles which in this instance have been adhered to, apart from the fact that Germany has already done precisely the same thing. There is the case of the vessel Trent during the American Civil War, when Confederate delegates, going to Europe in a British vessel for the purpose of raising funds for the South, were removed from the ship by the North American fleet. There is the case of the str.

China in the last war, when a number of enemy subjects were seized and removed to an internment camp in Hongkong. The case of the Sydney, a French vessel, from which three Americans going to China to assist her in the Sino-Japanese war were removed by the Japanese, has already been quoted, while the even more significant case of the British steamer Kowshing occurred in the course of the same campaign and needs to be remembered. This last instance while differing from the others in material particulars is of interest as showing exactly how far Japan herself has been prepared to prevent reinforcements reaching her enemy. On July 23, 1894, the British vessel Kowshing, belonging to the Indo-China Steam Navigation Ca. left Taku with over 1,200 Chinese troops on board destined for Korea. Two days later she was met by the Japanese cruiser Naniwa, under Captain Togo, later to attain much fame as Admiral Togo, and stopped. The ship's papers were examined, and the Kowshing instructed to follow the Naniwa. The troops on board mutinied and refused to allow the British captain and officers either to follow the Naniwa or leave the ship, whereupon after discharging a torpedo at her which missed, the Naniwa opened fire and sunk her. War between China and Japan was not declared until August 1, so that at the time Japan could not even claim belligerent rights in justification for sinking the neutral vessel. The British Foreign Office holding, however, that the war had actually commenced on July 23 at 4 am. when the Japanese invaded the Palace at Seoul, accepted the decision that the Japanese were within their rights in sinking a transport, even though it was a neutral vessel, in which enemy troops re-

It iso of importance to remember that in the course of the China Incident, the Japanese Navy has stopped and inspected British shipping, including the Rajputana, and though it never actually occurred, it is npi to be believed that if the Japanese had found emissaries of the Chinese National Government on board they would Se nave hesitated for one moment about taking them prisoner. The position of the British Government in this matter is perfectly clear. There has been a formal declaration of war and it follows that the Allies are in full possession of belligerent rights, which in the circumstances it would be the height of folly to fail to exercise. It must be obvious that, with Germany in possession of a back door through Russia and across Siberia, the blockade cannot be confined to Europe alone, and even though the amount of supplies she might receive over the trans-Siberian Railway may indeed be small, the Allies are quite within their rights to seek to prevent goods reaching Germany by that route. Hence the recent stopping and diversion of a Soviet steamer bound from Manila to Vladivostock with a cargo suspected to be contraband. Again it must be emphasized that Germany having universal conscription, all men of military age must be regarded as soldiers, even though there may be no indication of the units to which they may belong, and if British fishermen on a neutral vessel are liable to be captured, so must also enemy soldiers travelling on a neutral ship, even though that vessel is Japanese. It surely cannot be contended that if contraband of war destined for Germany is carried in Japanese bottoms it is immune from seizure, for if indeed that could possibly be the case, then the Japanese could expect to be allowed to carry edrgoes of war material through the Allied blockade which it would thereby render completely impotent. This proposition has merely to be stated te demonstrate its own absurdity. It is to be regretted that what after all is merely an ordinary process of war should have aroused such great resentment, especially when it is shown that Great Britain has in the past adopted a more obliging line than is now taken by the Japanese Government. The method of procedure has been correct, and courteous in every respect, and there can be no real ground for criticism.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account