The Archive · 1938

A Bitter Fight

"Big business" is for the moment very un-ar with President Roosevelt's adminis-on and Mr. Harold Ickes's speech in Washington on January 23 adds very great emphasis to the broadcast which he made on December 30 last On that ace; he indulged in a most vitriolic philippic, accusing the big businessmen of the United States of being united in a sit down strike to punish and probably destroy the New Deal. Mr. Ickes, who is the Secretary of the Interior, alleged that "an irreconcilable conflict between the power of money and the power of democratic instinct has reached such intensity in recent months that it is clear that it must be fought to a finish—until plutocracy or democracy—until America's sixty families (who control more than half the wealth of the country, or America's 120,000,000 people—They are alleged to have made the that unless they are allowed to speculate free of regulations, unless they are free to dominate the rest of the population without restrictions on their financial and economic power the United States will have its first strike, not of Labour, but of the pital created by the whole American people of which the sixty families have obtained so much control. Three principal offenders in the eyes of Mr. Ickes are Mr. Henry Ford, accused of trying to defy constitutional authority, Mr. Girdler, president of the Republican Steel Corporation, who led the opposition to the steel strike, and Mr. Rand, president of Remington Rand, accused, though subsequently acquitted, of unfair strike breaking activities. Mr. Ford was also accused Mr. Ickes of running the gamut from sect sabotaging to open defiance in his contemptuous disregard of the people's mandate and declared to be not entitled to the respect of decent law-abiding citizens. This is most unusual talk for a Cabinet Minister to indulge in, even in the United States, and when it is remembered that the broadcast was made with the President's approval it is even more astonishing.

This declaration of war on America's leading capitalists arises over their opposition to the New Deal. They had always disliked it, and the President's contention is that when perity returned they endeavoured to Government to abandon its reforms, and finding that impossible they had decided that the time had come to kill off Mr. Roosevelt by killing prosperity. It is believed that democracy will survive this new opposition, but it is plain from what Mr. Ickes has said that, should it fail to dose, a dictatorship the Right or the Left was sure to The danger it is contended lay in the concentration in the hands of a small atic class of economic power over other ur, lives and wealth. There is obviously wrong in any national iccumulation of money to the extent of half its wealth secure a position from which they can tate its economic future. Improperly used, that wealth may prove the deciding factor as to how long a particular type of government shall last, and can by manipulation on the markets bring about that state of affairs which tan rob a nation of the prosperity it has fought so hard to attain. How far the recent setbacks in the United States are directly attributable to the operations of the big interests now under attack is not clear, but it must be apparent that when their e so small and the community of interest so great their mobilization for any economic venture must inevitably cause the These men retort to the charges made by the administration that it is the latter who has failed, that the policy of priming the pump brought about a fictitious prosperity which commenced to recede directly the amount of priming was reduced. The feud between the Government and big business must of necessity be a bitter one, for both are fighting for their very existence and neither may be expected to make any voluntary surrender.

It is estimated that these wealthy leaders have sacrificed no less a sum than $30,000,- 000,000 in security values for the purpose of thwarting the progress towards recovery, and that manufacturers have cheerfully consented to a reduction of their production by 25 per cent. all for the purpose of embarrassing the It does, however, justify the thought that the specifies he devised were much slower in This journal during the early days of the New Deal pointed out that it was likely to prove a most expensive process, and that the prosperity so attained would be by no means cheap. There seems to be no reason for changing that view. Experience has proved that emergence from the slough of depression is a slow, laborious, self-sacrificing task. Prosperity to last has to be built on solid foundations. The operation of economic law is inevitable. Unsound policies have unfortunate results, and when the achievements of the New Deal are compared with their cost, there can be no cause for surprise if big business is so ruthlessly opposed to it. On the other hand should Mr. Ickes's charges be found to be correct, the Administration will be perfectly entitled to take whatever proper steps it may consider necessary to curb the power of its opponents, The first step would seem to be the extinction of monopolistic institutions, and the second may prove to be the enactment of taxation along lines, similar to the death duties in Great Britain through the operation of which huge fortunes in the course of a few generations go Pace to the people out of whom they were made.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account