The Archive · 1939

MORE HESITATION

The news received in Shanghai on Monday night to the effect that Anglo-Russian conversations for an understanding along anti-aggression lines had been reached between the two countries has, unhappily proved to be incorrect, and the fact emerges that the latest British proposals to the Kremlin have been found unsatisfactory, chiefly, it is to be presumed, because Great Britain was not willing to commit itself to that degree of reciprocity which Russia demands. The trouble is apparently due to the fact that there are certain members of Mr. Chamberlain's Cabinet who still regard an Anglo-Soviet Alliance with considerable distrust, and even go the length of opposing it, though the atmosphere in the House of Commons on Monday night as indicated by the question which were asked on the subject, suggests that there is in that body very considerable support for it. Mr. Chamberlain, himself, it is reported is by no means enthusiastic about such an understanding, and is bowing to the necessities of the situation rather than to any real liking for the inclusion of Russia in his anti-aggression scheme. It is possible that the restraint for which the man is remarkable prevents him at the moment from drawing all the morals from the lessons which have been taught him since Munich and the signing of the Anglo-Italian Pact, and while moderation is at all times to be commended, there may very well be occasions when, if allowed to prevail too much in the counsels of a nation, it may induce a hesitancy likely to take much of the effectiveness out of countermeasures designed to operate solely in th case of aggression. Russia is perfectly justified, when meeting any request for assistance in the event of onslaughts upon small nations under British and French guarantees, in demanding that whatever help she may be able to give shall have a counterpart in the assistance she should be entitled to receive in the event of her own territories becoming involved in hostilities, Hence the Soviet disquiet that British proposals up to the present do not provide against the possibility of any attack upon Russia herself in the event of her giving aid to Poland.

Between the Baltic states and Finland there is a stretch of Russian coast for which Moscow naturally requires Anglo-French guarantees, and M. Stalin is quite obviously going to enter into no bargain which does not provide for the reciprocation to the fullest degree of what Russia may be able to contribute to the common cause. The Russian, and presumably the French ideal is the formulation of a tri-particle agreement for self-defence including Great Britain in which the responsibilities and commitments of all parties thereto shall be equal and mutual. The exclusion of Russia during the talks of last year, due to the fact that it was impossible to include that country in the face of dictator opposition, has ever since been a sore point with that nation. The annoyance is not alleviated when it is remembered that it is as a result of the betrayals which have occurred since that the democracies are now seeking to number Russia amongst those bent on establishing a common front against the possibility of aggression by the dictatorships which cannot now be disregarded no matter how bland may be their assurances of an overwhelming desire for peace. What those members of the Cabinet who even now hesitate from committing Great Britain to a complete alliance with Russia appear to overlook is that the present is no time for half measures, that Russia has every just reason on her side for insisting that her partnership with the democracies shall be subject to no modifications, and that what is sought from her shall be guaranteed unto her. As was pointed out in these columns only a. few days ago, this modified system of collective defence cannot possibly succeed unless all those participating in it are unreservedly pledged to go to the assistance of any or all who may at one time or another be attacked. That type of understanding, and that alone is the only real guarantee that the new alignment will be able to withstand all the onslaughts which may be made upon it. It is the only answer to the German-Italian Military Alliance which is to be signed in the course of a few days."

With the adhesion of Turkey to the British plan a definite obstacle has been placed in the way of the German march from Berlin to Baghdad. That can be made all the more imposing and powerful with an Anglo-Russian understanding which is best calculated to provide that amount of reinforcement in the Balkans, and the Near East which alone can thwart Axis ambitions in that part ofthe world. Russian neutrality in the event of the outbreak of war will not be enough, if it can be shown that active assistance for the democratic cause could have been obtained by a degree of compliance which ihe British Government has shown little indications up to the present of giving. A neutral Russia could very well be the source of valuable supplies to the Axis, which it is desirable the latter should not have access to in the event of an outbreak of war. The present successes of British diplomacy would to a very considerable extent be discounted if negotiations with Russia end in failure. They will end so if there is much more reluctance to admit Russia into a full partnership in the system which Mr. Chamberlain is seeking to set up for the peace of Europe. A peace ensured by strength is only good so long as that strength is predominant against whatever can be marshalled to confront it. In these days of power politics, when it is might alone which tells, it is necessary that those regarded as potential menaces to peace should have it brought home to them that every disposition has been made to ensure that war shall end disastrously for them, should they be so foolhardy as to engage in one. It is not now, therefore, the time to permit of any hesitancies delaying the attainment of the fullest and most reciprocal agreement with Russia. To seek to set whatever aid she might be able to give at its proper value is a perfectly correct thing to do, but to endeavour to reach a bargain dependent upon the capabilities of each rather than upon the common acceptance of full and mutual responsibilities is to seek to enter into an arrangement as full of pitfalls as it must be of seeds of suspicion, Kulangsu Reflections Admiral Sir Percy Noble's visit to Am H.M.S. Birmingham and. the despatch of the U.S.S. Marblehead from Tsingtao to the same port indicate the serious view taken by the British and American Governments of the International Settlement on the island of Kulangsu. It is believed this is the first time Amoy waters have seen two foreign cruisers in port together. A number of interpretati have been placed on the reason for Japanese action in this tiny settlement, and in some circles it is believed to be a gesture which might be repeated elsewhere if it is unresisted. Reinforcing this belief is the series of demands presented to the Kulangsu Municipal Council which are tantamount to Japanese control of the administration, Whatever are the reasons, certain facts should be made clear. There is no legal or treaty provision abrogated by the landing of Japanese forces on Kulangsu. As a party to the international basis of Kulangs the Japanese are perfectly entitled to land forces to protect their own nationals and their property if they believe they are ned. The same condition applies to the ibility of landing British or American been carrying out since 1927 and have landed prior to this date for purposes of protection. The main point—and one on which London and Washington are in complete and determined agree: ment—is that there shall be no interference with the administration of the Kulengeu Municipal Council, and appropriate diplomatic procedure has been adopted to convey n, in no equivocal terms, the displeasure the British and American Governments will record at this form of action in Kulangsu or any other area possessing similar treaty basis. Reports of conditions in Kulangsu, as reported by a correspondent in another column, show that the position of the island has not been happy for some time prior to the landing. Caught between the cross fire of the hostilities, a state of blockade has been in existence and food supplies have been seriously curtailed, only small quantities of food, chiefly vegetables, g transported to the island from the mainland by junks owned or chartered by foreigners. Food prices have doubled in consequence of this and the influx of Chinese refugees from the mainland, and Japanese raids on Chinese positions on the mainland have been conducted from a part of the shallow beach outside Amoy where a temporary air base has been created for facilitating operations. On the conduct of the war there can be no comment. That is Japan's own affair. Bot any assault on the position of Kulangsu, the smallest of the foreign areas created by treaty and an integral part of the whole system of legally-constituted settlements in China, grave matter which the Powers have not been slow in perceiving.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account