The Archive · 1938

A Wise Verdict

It is one of the good points about the jury system that juries do quite often come between a defendant and the passionless application of the law, and the case of Dr. Aleck William Bourne, senior obstetrician of St. Mary's Hospital, London, is an excellent example of what is meant, Some weeks ago a young girl was the victim of a criminal assault, for which two young soldiers have been sent to penal servitude for four years, and a third, merely charged with attempt, to hard labour for twenty-two months. The girl was subsequently found to be pregnant, and Dr. Bourne performed an operation which relieved her of that consequence of the men's evil act. He accepted no fee for what he did, and, in order to test.the whole legal position, informed Scotland Yard of what he had done. A summons was issued, and, following preliminary hearings, he was committed for trial at the Old Bailey, where the jury found him not guilty of the offence charged under Section 58 of the Offences Against the Person Act of 1861. Mr. Justice Macnaghten in his summing up drew the necessary distinction between the case and that of professional abortion, and the jury rendered a decision on a long standing issue which had thus been brought to a head by the action of the defendant doctor. In taking the steps he did Dr. Bourne showed himself possessed of the courage of his conviction, for, if he had failed to establish his case, not only would he have had to suffer the penalties provided by the law, but it is conceivable that the General Medical Council would have had to investigate the matter with a view to his removal from the medical resister. He was, therefore, not only imperilling his liberty by what he did, but running the risk of being deprived of the right to earn his livelihood in the profession in which he is an eminent figure. The real question at issue was not whether he had committed a breach of the law, but whether in the circumstances he was justified in what he did. The jury appears to have come to the conclusion that there was justification for the line of conduct he had pursued, and that is to be taken as the real significance of their verdict.

From earlier reports to hand it appears that many members of the medical profession expressed their warm appreciation of the manner in which Dr. Bourne had faced issues vitally important to the profession and general public, and there is every probability that, had a conviction been obtained, considerable agitation would have been set afoot to relieve him of whatever penalty might have beea inflicted. The decision, nevertheless, is bound to create a storm of controversy. On the one side there will be those of the very definite conviction that once the process of life has commenced it should not be interfered with. It is a view which, for reasons spiritual, moral and ethical, cannot be lightly set aside, and in the generality of cases it is one which in the communal interest cannot be denied. Too wide an opening of the door in this respect would entail grave dangers, to the moral stamina of a nation, and for that reason the merit of the general doctrine has to be conceded. But there is in this present case questions of absolute justice which may permit some modification of the general principle. They may be summed up quite briefly:—Should the victim of this outrage be permitted to suffer what might be a life-long penalty for a grievous wrong perpetrated upon her? Should she be condemned to the ignominy of having to bring an illegitimate child into the world, to provide for its maintenance, and suffer all the disadvantages which a woman in such a condition much necessarily endure? The wrong-doing has not been hers: and a rigid application of the principle which has been conceded above would inevitably mean that this young girl would be condemned to suffer the continuing penalty of her innocence. Justice demands that the innocent shall not be punished, but unless Dr. Bourne, or some other medical man equally inspired with the sentiments which apparently dominated him, had come to this child's rescue, all the innocency in the world would not have relieved her from the future pain and suffering-which must have followed. Those considerations appear to have influenced not only the jury, but also the judge, and in this conflict between the law and human conception of justice the latter has been allowed to prevail.

The law cannot be drafted to meet all cases. As G. N. Lewis has written "Exact laws, like all other ultimates and absolutes, are as fabulous as the crock of gold at the rainbow's end." The jury's decision was not the only solution of the problem presented, though it was certainly the most effective. Had they performed what in all the circumstances appears to have been their bounden duty, they could have presented a verdict of guilty with a recommendation to mercy, and the Judge might very well then have passed upon the defendant a purely nominal sentence. That would have been a vindication of the law, but a denial of that justice which Dr. Bourne sought upon the broader principles of common humanity. In effect his case to the jury was "Here are the facts, do you believe, in view of all that has happened, that I was not justified in taking the course I did?" The jury gave the reply he had the right to expect in view of all the circumstances, and in doing so vindicated those ideals of justice which cannot always find expression in legal textbooks, for the simple reason that it is impossible to legislate against all possible contingences. If ever there were a case in which a "true deliverance" has been made between "our sovereign lord the King and the prisoner at the Bar" it is undoubtedly here, and while legal purists may deplore departure from bounden duties, those who desire that substantial justice shall prevail in the world will be gratified by its result. Fortunately, the decision involves no radical change of the law on the subject, nor any abatement of principles. Dr. Bourne sought to remedy a grievous wrong as far as it was possible by the exercise of his professional skill. He made no secret of what he did, and he is to be congratulated on the moral courage and public spirit which he has displayed. in this matter. It is a tribute to the humanity of his profession and the high-mindedness which sought a decision on a very difficult problem.

Whose the Fault The correspondence on the subject of "War or Peace" is tending to follow the usual lines, and now a correspondent goes back to the old familiar argument that the only people who want war are munitions manufacturers. It is possible that the same reproach was levelled against the bowyer and the fletcher in those days before the invention of gunpowder commenced to confer such added terrors to the inevitable struggles between kingdoms and races. Their answers to the reproach would be the same as that which the manufacturers of the more advanced weapons of today rely upon. It is a simple one. There would be no munitions manufacture if there were no demand for such goods, that demand creates the supply and not vice versa. That there are very unpleasant aspects to the trade in arms and munitions, that their manufacturers can hardly escape from the reproach of fostering enmities, and indulging in intrigues for the furtherance of their trade has to be admitted. All this, however, is but symptomatic of the real evil, and that is that humanity has not yet arrived at that state of advancement which enables it to see that war settles nothing, but breeds occasions for the renewal of the struggle. Mankind is possessed of the ability of preventing war, if it will but make use of if. Were it to do so the munitions makers would be speedily out of business, and, when international violence becomes as unfashionable as the bow and arrow, the makers of today's highly ingenious weapons of destruction will follow the bowyer and the fletcher out of business. It is all very well to select the munitions manufacturer as the whipping boy for humanity's faults, but it has no more justification than blaming the grower of vines and the distiller for the evil results of abuse of their products. Destroy the demand and the suppliers will have to turn their attention to other activities. That is certainly not an easy remedy, but so long as humanity is what it is the total elimination of arms manufacture would not necessarily banish war. Staves znd stones would still be available.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account