Claim for C. $1,224 for Alleged Defective Cloth Brought by German In dismissing a suit brought by Mr. Richard W. Louis against the Wing On Ca. Fed, Inc. for selling him allegedly detective cloth, in the U.S. Court yesterday, Judge N. E. Lurton said that when a person buys something in a shop, and no guarantee is given by the vendor. the burden of the sale rests with the buyer, under the law of caveat emptor. If the buyer makes the purchase, having inspected the article, he is presumed to know what he is buying, since he is under no compulsion to purchase, and ceti take or leave the goods as he wishes. As long as the seller does ^ot misrepresent the articles he sells, the responsibility rests on the buyer.
Mr. Louis a tailor, claimed US$100 as damages to his reputation, and Mx $1224 from the Wing On Ca, representing the cost of 52 yards of cloth at C. N. $5.15 & yard, and the cost of making the cloth into men's suits. The cloth, Alleged the plaintiff, proved defect tive, since five suits made of it, which he sold, were returned to him in a torn condition after being washed only ence. In the witness box he stated that early in the summer he went to Wing On's and bought there on three occasions, 52 yards of material, at an average price of $5.15 a yard. This material he made up into Suits and sold to four clients. The süits were later returned to Him with Ti the complaint that they were not durable, since the cloth tore after one wash. On approaching the Wing On Ca. he was offered reimbursement for "ithe unused cloth, and a certain amount for the cloth in the sui would not accept what they offered hit. He stated that he was an expert in cloth and tailoring, having owned a select tailor's shop in Berlin.
Mr. C. S. Franklin, representing the Wing On Company, stated that his fients are retailers, and offered no tee with this cloth, since the quality of merchandise sold by them is in line with the price paid by the buyer, and the price of $5.15 a yard is cheap. American law states that it a person buys something, being able to inspect what he buys, there being no guarantee by the seller, the purchaser is entirely at liberty to take leave the article, and if he does buy; it is only because he considers the price reasonable. There was, moreover, stated Mr. Franklin, no im-Rnowteage of defects equal to that of lied guarantee if the buyer had
the seller, as was the case In this suit.
Dr. Walter Fuchs represented the plaintiff.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.