Sup, 328, the facts are meagerly: stated but It appears that the Getendant undertook for money to sell fan immigration visa from the Amer!~ can Consulate in Niagra Falls. Canada, to an alien by Impersonating Immigration officer of the United States, In. United States v. Ter~ ranova, 7 Fed. Sup. 989. the @efendant was subcontractor of a Government building under construc tion and employed workmen at a lesser wage than the prevailing wage cole, but by requiring the workmen to sign false payrolls, made It appear the Government that the workmen were being paid the prevailing wage. In. United States _v. Haas, 163 Fed. 908, the conspirators, by bribery. by Indueed an employee of the Department of Agriculture to furnish them With, departmental reports onthe often crop in advance of the official The ease before the Court is a close one, However, it will be noticed that In the typical cases cited the conspirators either impersonated a Government oMlecr. or by fraud Induced oF defeated governmental action, In the Instant case it does not appear that defendant enlisted any fagsistance or participation of the Consulate in the furtherance of his Scheme. The Consulate has neither however. done nor left undone anything on his Fdueoment which it has had to core eet, 'The Consulate declined Fegister the American-Chinese Ca. as. fan American firm and did nothin except to write 9 routine letter to Gefendant, According to the informa Vion, the defendant altered this Tetter and' photostatieally reproduced it on the "eertifeate," Obviously this was lane to lend an appearance of vent to the recital in the "certificate." that the American-Chinese Ca. was duly registered In the American Consulate General, but this alteration and misuse of the Consulate letter was the subsequent and sole act of the defendant, Th United States Byers un Fed, (24) 419, it was held that a subseaent breach of faith after the consummation of transaction with fin agency of the United States was rot 1 defrauding of the United States.
the opinion of the Court, the alteration -and misuse of the letter doublies constitutes un ordinary case fof forgery under the District of Columbia Code because the law is well settled that forgery may committed by the alteration of ftenuine instrument as well as by apricating a whole one, In the opinion of the Court, the information docs not present a" asin of conspiracy to defraud the United States because no official purpose has been defeated be" misrepresentation to. or overreaching of. any official "charged with carrying out the gov-emmental intention 'Conspiracy charges are nos favoured when the overt act Is a complete offence in itself. Some Federal courts have held that' sine" a combination of persons is the cist of the crime of conspiracy, at least two. persons must be tried and convicted and that one defendant alone cannot be con-
Vieted, but the weight of authority is probably to the contrary.
The demurrer will he sustained in far of the information attempts charge a conspiracy to commit forgery of a certificate of redistre and a con-
Soiracy to defraud the United States.
The information is held suMeient to charge a conspiracy to commit an
wit, the crime of obtaining money under false pretences, in violation of the District of Columbia Code, and fo that extent the demurrer will be overruled. The District Attorney is advised to file an information for forgery of the letter.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.