fo the Editor of the form-Cuiwa Day News"
'Sm—As I understand it, according the present regulation of the Shanghai Fire Insurance Association, fon the pain of penalty, the insurer must receive from the' insured the exact net insurance premium 2s: shown in the premium receipt. no further discount or rebate being al-Towed. Out of the net premium so received, the insurer then pays 10 the relative broker a commission of 20 per cent. or even 30 per cent.
Teonsider such commission excess sive. It is often out of all proportion {o the supposed service performed by the broker. It paves the way to un det hand and dishonest practices, th enterprising broker. in order to com: pete for business, frequent giving away a part of his commission secret rebate to the insured, the Association ruling notwithstanding, Tam connected with a local whose annual insurance amounts to, 1US$700,000 and which pays annually 'a net premium of some' US§2,000, The firm's policy is to disregard all brokers and to entrust all its extensive business to the one insurance company, which it considers as the most reliable, Supposing the usual broker's commission to be 20 per cent. out of the aid by the above nee company will have to pay a broker's commission—if one such broker exists—of USS400. equivalent today to about Shanghai $5,000, The question is, how this sum of $5,000 should be disposed of, The path of least resistance is for the insurance company to create, without the knowledge and approv the insured, one or several im= aginary brokers to whom it then dis {tributes the above sum of $5,000, these imaginary brokers being probably men in the company's stai who had previously something to do in obtain= Ing the above firm's business. But the business being now directly entrusted by the firm to the insurance company, the broker's role is not a real, but'an imaginary. one, To kee on paying comfortable commission 10 such imaginary broker or brokers is unfair and unreasonable.
Had there been no Association ruling, the most reasonable way would be to refund this amount of '$5.000 to the firm in the form of re-ie. In making this refund, the in= france company loses nothing, for refund Is not an extra payment. but merely a substitute for the usual commission. The firm is its ow broker and is therefore entitled 10 the same broker's commission.
I venture to suggest that the Fire Insurance Association meet 10 consider its present regulation, with of protecting the best interest fof the insured. If under such cases the insurance company must keel the commission and will make no re facilitate the settlement of any future claims made by the relative insured si
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.