Coursey: Mr. <M, Reader, Harris for atu ind hi. oe ones for Before Sir Allan Masson, Judge.
(Adjourned.)
Shanghai, Oct, 25.
Claiming a total of $118,084.85 for alleged breach of contract, Mr, Loh Nanstsoo, contractor, represented by Mr, M. Reader Harris, is the plaintiff and Mr, R. M. Joseph, represented by Mr, J. R. Jones, is the defendant in an action heard by Sir Allan Mossop, Judge, in HM. Supreme Court yes: terday. "The hearing, which lasted the whole day, was adjourned to 10 am,, Oct, 25, after Mr, Reader Harris hhad"examined his client in the wite ness-box, while Mr. Jones was able to start his cross-examination, In_ compliance with the terms written agreement signed between the two parties on June 12, 1937, plaintiff was to supply material and Tabour for the construction of an apartment house on Avenue Joffre, at 1 price of $203,000 and the building was to be completed on or before June 16, 1998, Mr. Harris stated in opening his. pleadings, According to the agreement, plaintim was to receive payments for the work completed and materials bought Upon presentation of the usual cer-Neate issued by the architects, Messrs. Davies, Brooke & Gran, it being understood that 20 per cent. of all amounts due should be withheld until six months after the com= pletion of the building, while the Amounts payable at any one time would have to be over $10,000, Mr, Harris added.
On November 2, 1997, the frst statement amounting to $1,051 was presented, but only' $15,000 were paid Gefendanty'Me. Hans added, although he would have been entitled Feceive 8 per cent. of the original Amount. The balance thus due, Mr. Harris continued, was to have bee aid his. client pon. resumption of work which was) interrupted asa result of Sino-Japanese hostilities.
Mr. Harris alleged that defendant continuously. interfered " in matters which are enrively at the discretion of the architects and that in this way the architects were unable to. perform their duties impartially and discreetly as set out in the "agree ment and in compliance with the Teyal status of avehiteets who actually fact as intermediaries between the contractor and the owner of the building, The total amount of the claim in= eludes $45,000 which plaintiff is al-Toged to have deposited with the defendant as a surely for the fulflment of the agreement; $42,270.38 for Work and materials supplied by the plaintiff; $80,160.69" for" plants" and machinery on the site and $644.48 for additional materials.
The entire morning and the carly part of the afternoon wore taken up by Mr. Reader Harris who, in pute ting hig ease before the court, read oura large number of letters ox-changed between the two parties, and quoted from the judgments vendered in the case of Roberts v. Hickman & Ca. in 1913, in which, he claimed, the circumstances were practically the same as in the present case.
Mz. Loh in giving evidence later in the afternoon told the Court that he was a building contractor Shanghai and that he had been in this business for the past seventeen years.
On' June 12, 1997, he added, he entered an eyreement with the' defendant for the erection of an apartment building on Avenue Joftee, Work being commenced immediately" When hostilities broke out in August that year, witness continued, work had to "be suspended owing. to the Inability on his. part, to secure the Tabour "and materials "req In Feply to 8 question by His Lordship, witness said that he owned two yards, one on Ferry Road. and the other' at the corner" of Ferry" and Penang Roads. On November 8, 1937, hho added, he' put in an application for the first payment of $84,000. but the architect, witness claimed, only certified $15,000, promising to' Issue a certifeate for the balance when work would be resumed.
"In view of the fact that work had been suspended and that Mr, Brooke (of Messrs. Davies, Brooke & Gran) had given me his' assurances that would get the rest as soon as. the work Would start "again" witness continued, "I accepted this amount."
On March 1, 19%8, witness said, he received a letter from the architects, Fequesting him to start work again within fourteen days, and wone was started before March 14.
On "March 26, witness stated, one other application was forwarded to the architects for "$5,660 In. respect to the extra cost" of additional materials purchased for the completion of foundation work. trid, although no reply was received, work fas continued, being completed May 20, on which day, witness. per= sonally presented another application for $13,560.15 to Mr. Brooke, who alleged' to-have told him that (Loh) would receive the certificate on, the following day.
"When I saw Mr. Brooke the following "day," witness continued, "he showed me a letter from. the fendant's: agents, Messrs. Atkinson Dallas, Ltd, stating that the archi acts should" not give me the certl-Hieate but that 1 would" receive a ter in due course. I then received letter demanding assurances that Work would be carried out. puno tually im future. "Tin turn replied to the architects in writing, pointing out my. position.
Extracts from the letter in ques tion were then read to the Court from which it transpired that unless plaintiff received the money. due him in addition to a compensation towards the increase in the costs of materials, he could give no assur 'On May 23, witness added, a further application for $8,113.60 cover-Ing cost of extra purchases of materials was handed to Mr, Brooke and on May 31, he received' a letter complaining of' the fact that inthe opinion of the architects, there were insufficient materials on the site and threatening that a change in contractors would be made unless cer-lain work, specified in the contract, was completed within four 'Witness stated, however, the time he had' suMicient' materials fon the sile to. work for the following seven days while additional materials had. already been ordered and would be delivered by that time so that no delay would be caused, Work: was then carried on until June 25, when Messrs. J. F. sil DK, Silby, R. M, Joseph and Victor Priestwood, who at the time acted as solicitor for the defendant, arrived at the site in the company of a Inrge number of French Con. cession policemen who ordered all workmen 10" leave within ten minutes and, according to counsel for the plaintiff, did not even permit members of the staff to inform plaintiff of what had happened, over the telephone, Witness went on to state that when he was informed of this, he immediately went to the police to ask for reasons for the eviction and later received g written report from the police. The matter was reported 10 the architects and ina letter dated June 28, they informed him that they had no knowledge of the occurrence, Witness then described at length the dificutties which he had to face while working on defendant's site, in. view of the fact that the agents, who Were also a firm of architects," gave instructions for alterations of" work In course of completion. ave further details as to the all Interference by the agents.
Cross-examining, Mr, Jones, asked witness whether he had worked in collaboration with Messrs. Davis, Brooke & Gran on previous occasions during his seventeen years as a contractor, Plaintiff said that he had and that among the buildings con~ structed on behalf of this firm, is the Medhurst Apartment Building.
reply to another question, witness sated" that he was fully familiar with the terms of contracts such as the one signed between him and plaintiff, Asked whether the, $15,000 due him on the first cer tine ate had bet Mr. reply, to further questions, witness added that Messrs. Davies, Brooke & Gran had given him every facility "for purchasing materials and that he had deposited money with them in order that they should, Procure certain materials, such as cement, for him, He denied, how-fever, that the cement which—was ought at that time was. cheaper than prior to the local hostilities, Did you know that Mr, Joseph way very concerned about the delay the resumption of work?™, Mr, Jones asked, "Yes, but the reasons for the delay' were beyond my control and I was prepared to carry out the contract, Irrespective, of the higher price of materials," Mr, Loh replied.
Mr, Jones—"I put it 10 you, that in your letter to: the architects, you stated that you would have 10 re~ ceive payment $5,600 as otherwise you would be unable to go on with the. work Mr. Loh:—"T always, submit my applications to the architects who, being impartial, decide, Mr, Jones:—"Did Mr, Brooke tell you that this claim was excessive?
Mr, Loh:—"Yes, but sometimes we! ask for" $1,000 and only get $200 and In reply. to another question, witness stated thal Ar. Brooke always knew how much materials were on the site.
'Mr, Jones then referred to a meet-Ing which took place on April 8 and Jat'which Messrs, -Priestwood, Joseph, Brook and the' plaintiff attended. He asked whether witness had then' said that he was unable to avoid the
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.