The Archive · 1939

Reluctance and Delay

March 16. very long last the Council has felt itself obliged to let the ratepayers know what, actually was the result of the negotiations which took place in connection with the Japanese demands arising out of the cameign of terrorism. It is believed that there was some sort of understanding between the authorities concerned that secrecy would bbe preserved os to what was happening, and while the Council seems to have adhered to the bargain, information, inaccurate some' minor respects, but substantially correct, was to. be obtained from Japanese circles and even from Tokyo. Finally as stated in the announcement issued on Tues~ day, in view of the misleading reports regarding the understanding recently reached between the Council and the Japanese authorities the former decided to make the situation quite clear, Whether the Council! was well advised in agreeing in the first place to secrecy is debatable. It is possible fo conceive instances where the completest Feticonce is desirable, but if that cannot be obtained, if for some reason or other sul.

lent information gets abroad to permit of} garbled reports and wild rumour, then it is} clearly the duty of the Council' to reveal the actual state of affairs as speedily as possible. This latest announcement which it has made is welcomed as a perfectly cor eet step to have been taken in the eireum= stances; the only possible criticism is that it! was taken so late, The policy of the Council with regard to publicity has never been entirely satisfactory. For many years past! it has sought to cloud its deliberations in an altogether unacceptable mystery, and though when a Press Relations Officer was appointed in 1931 it was believed that a better system of publicity would be evolved, the virtual abolition of that office and the relegation of the incumbent's duties to an official in the Secretariat has practically brought about that state of affairs which caused the agita-leading to the appointment of a Com= mission to consider the whole matter some eight or nine years ago.

Penetration into the municipal arena by the representatives of the Press is a matter of very considerable dimeulty, chiefly because the present policy of secrecy makes it neces~ sary that journalists should know what to askj—and that very generally means. that! they have a shrewd idea of what the answer will be—knowledge which they have had to obtain by roundabout methods which serve to indicate how difficult it is, in view. of the present composition of the Council, to maintain quite that airtight secrecy which it, has been the consistent endeavour of the authorities to maintain. The information which the Council is prepared to volunteer the public is generally weeks late, as witness the monthly departmental reports, which at the end of February or beginning of March serve to tell Shanghai what it was like, say, for example, in January. Informa tion some weeks after the event, as to how many plants were laid out in the Public Parks, the state of Shanghai's health, the number of roadwidenings and the state of Shanghai's crime may prove of interest if published as closely as possible to the end of the period under review, but if that publication is unduly delayed the information eases to have anything but a purely academical interest. It will be seen, therefore, that' the two main failings of the Council's policy arise first from reluctance and secondly from delay. In the case of the announcement issued on Tuesday night with regard to the Council's negotiations with the Japan~ ese authorities' incorrect reports appearing, for the most part in newspapers in Japan have had uncontradicted currency for the eleven days between March 3, when the negotiations came to an end, and March 14 when the Council eventually broke its silence. It is apparent now that the Coun-li's hand was forced by the untrue reports and rumours which had gained currency, and its hand having thus been forced after so long an interval, is it to be believed that those untruths will ever be overtaken?

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account