The Archive · 1940

Useless Peace Talk

To all intents and purposes the Battle of Flanders has ended, and Mr. Anthony Eden, Secretary for War, made that clear when he issued a statement on Sunday stating that four-fifths of the British expeditionary force sent to Flanders, in response to the appeal of Belgium and Holland, has been safely withdrawn. As that force amounted to 300,000 men it follows that nearly a quarter of a million British soldiers have been safely extricated from the trap which the Germans nearly closed, and in which they boasted of being able to annihilate all the Allied forces. Together with the British, French and Belgian troops have also been evacuated, and there apparently remains around Dunkirk a comparatively small rearguard whose rescue will become increasingly difficult as their numbers are reduced by evacuation. It is inevitable that some of these men will have to be sacrificed, for it is manifestly impossible to get all of them out. That the number will be reduced to a minimum may be taken for granted. A large amount of Allied war material had necessarily to fall into enemy hands but it was destroyed, or rendered useless until it has passed through the smelting furnaces of Germany. Thus the first phase of the German Blitzkrieg has ended. The enemy has won a battle at a cost which must amaze even those who realized the enormous forces which the Germans threw into this struggle, and the wanton and callous manner in which the German high command wasted men and material in order to bring about a victory which has been completely offset by the enormous cost at which it has been achieved, and the fact that it has completely failed of its major objective,—the destruction of the Allied forces which were sent into Flanders in reply to the appeal of the Low Countries. It was playing the German game to have done so, but promises had to be honoured even at the development of a risk from which the Allied forces have been able to save themselves. There is every reason for pride and devout thankfulness that Providence was on the side of the Allies, while it has been demonstrated that, with the courage of their men and the efficiency of their organization, they can face. the future with confidence undiminished.

But what of the future? The opinion is rapidly growing in Europe, that the attitude of the Italians will encourage Herr Hitler to hold his hand for a while during which neutral Powers will be given the opportunity to endeavour to persuade the Allies to agree to negotiate a peace. It is not suggested that Herr Hitler himself will formulate peace proposals but that through his inspiration some country at present unknown may come forward with suggestions. There is nothing in the situation as it stands at present to indicate that the Allies are in any way disposed to consider peace. There can be no peace on the terms which Herr Hitler ha: announced in the past, for that would en the sacrifice of all those nations whose wrongs the Allies are out to correct, and the surrender to other demands which could only be done in the event of a complete defeat of the Allies, They have not been defeated. They have lost territory in Flanders. They have inflicted grievous loss upon the enemy out of all proportion to the successes he has gained. The moral of their Armies is excellent, and even the men, who have undergone an experience which in the past was only dreamed of but never fully realized, have emerged from the struggle completely undaunted, and ready, after a rest, to go back and get on with the work of defeating the enemy. The prestige of the Allies has in no way suffered by the reverse they have suffered, and there is not one valid reason why they should consider peace until they have brought the enemy low. It is with that intention they embarked upon hostilities and it is with the same determination, that this evil thing which has battened upon Europe for all too long shall be wiped out, that they will continue with the fight. It is, therefore, no time to talk peace now. At the best it would be but another perilous armistice while the totalitarian Powers, with the experience which has already been gained, proceeded to improve their war machine for another combat in the hope that their chances then would be better than they appear to be now.

In the circumstances it would be the height of folly to consider doing anything but continue the struggle until the Allied aims have been achieved, for it is only by that means that Europe can ever hope to enjoy any lengthy period of tranquillity in which to set "about healing the grievous wounds which have already been inflicted upon it, and those others which may be confidently expected before this comes to an end. It is only necessary to ask what possible guarantees can ensure the peace of Europe to realize that so long as Naziism is permitted to continue, so long as the doctrine of might being right is permitted to remain current, so long must Europe remain under the shadow of fear. That fear must be removed if future generations are not to live as precariously as the present. It can only be dispelled by an Allied victory, and a peace in which the claims of all European Powers are disposed of with justice all round. Nevertheless it is to be expected that, following each and any success that the enemy may obtain, peace feelers will be sent out. It was the same thing on several occasions during the last war, and the number of occasions when Germany sought peace, not only when she was losing the war, but when to all intents and purposes she was winning it, will undoubtedly be equalled in this great struggle. The Allies are not likely to be cozened by fair words any more now than they were then. They have sustained no blow which should change that determination. Their armies stand intact. Their people are solidly behind them, determined to withstand all and everything the enemy can do and to endure until they have smashed a menace to the peace of the world which simply cannot in the interests of the whole of humanity be allowed to continue in existence. It may be that for some days there will be a lull, not only because the enemy will need to consolidate its gains, but because full opportunity for this anticipated peace manceuvre to succeed must be given. It will fail It is useless to talk of peace when there can be no peace, and the Allies must take advantage of whatever lull there may be to gird their loins for a continuance of a struggle the end of which is not yet in sight.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account