The Archive · 1941

N.E.I. Negotiations

The Government of the Netherlands East

Indies and Mr. Kenkichi Yoshizawa, the head of the Japanese delegation which has been attempting to negotiate a trade agreement between Japan and the Netherlands colony, have both announced with regret that the negotiations have been terminated, as a result of differences which cannot at present be bridged. The rock on which the parleys were wrecked has not been revealed, but it is possible to speculate on what it was with some accuracy when the reiterated that no political demands were made, The negotiations were purely economic. Tt is self-evident, however, that there may be differences of opinion as to where economic jan attemptrto "'demands ehä and political demands begin. T! "allegation con-. appears that the Japanese have insisted that "to the Netherlands East Indies "cooperate" in the "East Asia Ca-prosperity Sphere." This request may seem to the statesmen in Tokyo to be purely economic, while a totally different interpretation might well be put upon it in Batavia. This different interpretation might encouraged by the frequent claims voiced in Japanese. newspapers that Japan must be acknowledged to be the leader in this "sphere." The manner in which Indo-China has been included in the "sphere" has not proved a happy example. Moreover, if Japan's claims to leadership are pressed to their logical conclusion, it would entail acknowledgement of this leadership by the Philippines and the Straits Settlements, the first named under the protection of object-in the United States, and the latter a British colony. Neither the United States nor Great Britain would dream of consenting to any sort of economic overlordship by Tokyo. They that in would almost certainly regard any demand for similarity j such overlordship as political and outside the on the sea,' scope of purely trade negotiations. During the must be just concluded negotiations the British Empire and has played no part, having no locus standi. But and within very obvious that the Empire and the United States would both become vitally concerned Or Te- were the subject of political concessions intro-secondary duced and there be any threat to the in-tack on dependence of the East Indies. As Sir Robert Brooke-Popham pointed out some weeks ago, the Allies have a continuous defence line from Singapore, through the East Indies, and on to Australia. Any breach in this line would necessarily interest others beside the Netherlands East Indies, whose hand has probably been strengthened by this knowledge. There seems to have been no disposition on the part of the NEI. authorities to deny Japan vital raw materials, subject to the condition that none of these materials finds its way to Japan's Axis partners. Agreement would almost certainly have been reached had the negotiations been confined to this point. Mr, Yoshizawa, whom many will remember during his term of office in China, is one of Japan's ablest and most reasonable diplomats, and that the negotiations have broken down can be no fault of his. There can be no question at this time of partitioning the world into different spheres of influence. That must wait until the conflict has been decided before it can even be discussed; and even then, there must be no idea of partitioning, but rather a cementing of all interests into a common unity—a unity which will benefit all at the expense of none.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account