The Chinkiang collision cave.
The Court opened at 10.15 a.in.
Mr. Rostwsow appeared for the plaintiff and Mr, Waryewaicut for the defendants His Lorpsurr delivered the following en. Chinkiang. Sai Ore, m: and the junk Chinhuan-hsing, which oe ewrod in the Yung or Ningpo River at about 2,20 a.m, on 25th ut April, 1882, while the steamer and junk were rounding the point at the bottom of what is known to foreigners as Short Reach. The stermer was in charge of a licensed pilot, nud appears from the evidence to have kept a sond look-out, and have had hee regula-his burning. The case presents discrepancies lik appear to be inseparable from. Admiralty cases, aucivs appear to me case to be attri-
First of all with regard to the wind. The junk states that it was S.WV., that directly contrary to the direction of her course; and the Chinkiang saya it was WS.8., that also ws di would be hardly any wi all, and all wind each felt, de herself. Next there is the position of the jank. The junk says it was about 150 ft. from the south bank, and the Chinkiang says it was in mid channel. It was probably between the two. As to the want of lights on board of the junk, as Ian of is Kiang, were correct be observed, howe man and the pilot did not see the light on firat junk, which there can be no doubt did carry a light. The testimony of the junkmen is not so manifestly false therefore as to disc e it them upon other subjects. The next point about whic ict, us presented by Mr. Wainewright ting up, and the case on behalf junk, is that the junk says they continued their course while Mr.
2 of the Captain is with ner having altered I and in fact is strongly in support of the junk's story that she did not. He says in cross-examination "I did not expect that she was going to keep her course, when she was 300 fest off. I did not think she would follow the first junk. I do not think that Lough to have expected in accordance with utterly incor ion thet who did We are therefore con-the junkmen's direct many that they did not a memel delfting up with tide and doing Then the this—that
nothing when she syes a steamer ahead of her isan into by that steamer. Unless the 8 how that it was the duty of the junk to alter her cou ug the general rule ti shall keep it under such circus Nautical Aasossor thinks that the junk nut bound to alter her course, and 1 quite ugreo with him. But the ose of ti Chinkiang la that she was in auch @ posi tion that she cond do nothing without danger to herself. Now here both the Nautical Assessor and myself are clearly of opinion that, the: cvuree which ip. like the chinkiang must inevitably follow when rounding the point, The very firat thing that 1a on looking at it thatthe Chinkiang did not follow that course, but went considerably more to the North' than Mr. Hoar said was possible, and anyone looking at the course marked will see that this is natural, For about a cable's length "fter he has put hie helm hard-w-starboard, and before he gets the wad of the ship into the full force ut the but, yz, T.ther to starboard. current th does not go to port at all,
then for another cable's length he d not get her head round more than a quar.er of a point, All this is evidently, exaggeration. Then Mr. Vatighan sys:—"The result of keeping your engines dead slow at the point where I sxy [should starboard would be to fotch the South bank." Now the point where Mr. Vaushan says he should starboard is as jenny as possible the spot where Pilot Smith says he put the engines dead slow, hut the Chinkiang not only did not fete the South bank, but got herself somewhere
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.