The Archive · 1898

Saw Reports

H.B.M.'s CIVIL SUMMARY COURT

Shanghai, 10th May. Before Sir Nrcuotas J. Hannes, Chief Tustice.

Yo Am-over Marmaxp.

This was an action adjourned from Friday, the plaintiff, a mafoo, suing for wages and money expended in pony keep in the defendant's behalf. Defendant, Mr. Harry Maitland, alleged.that the bill was excess sive and.that the plaintiff had starved his ponies. Another mafoo who had rounded on him as to squeezing the ponies' food, failed to appear at the last hearing and the case was put back so that he might be called.

Mr. Nelson who represented the defendant, now apologised for the fact that he was not able.to bring the Chinaman who made the statement, but in the interests of sport and the public forelly Doctors Keylock and Pratt who had. soon the ponies had volunteered to give evidence.

Mr. Maitland was recalled and examined briefly. He spoke to the method of feeding the ponies and the quantity of corn allotted to each.

Mr. Sidney W. Pratt, M. R. C. V. S., said that he had been in the habit of riding the ponies in question. In the month of March he saw them and noticed that they were in very poor condition. He thought at first there was disease in the stable but on examination he found this was not the case. Their condition was due to one of two reasons, They were either doing too much work or not getting enough food. He knew however of his own knowledge that they were not over-worked and the amount of corn ordered by Mr. Maitland, fifteen pounds a day for Sammie, and twelve pounds a day for the others, was ample if it had-been served out to them. He had to treat them for weakness and put them on a proper feed, with the result that they speedily recovered and' were able to do their work satisfactorily.

Plaintiff' sought to show that it was not to his interest to starve the ponies inasmuch as it was the custom of every owner when he won a race to make a present to the mafoo. The improved condition of the ponies after his dismissal was due to the fact that towards the end of the training season they were given oats, deans, ete. As the head mafoo it was an honour to him when the ponies won.

Mr. Henry Keylock, M-R.O.V.S. next gave evidence. He was acquainted with the defendant's stable and had ridden most of the ponies. When his attention was called to the condition of the ponies in the middle of March he at once came to the conclusion that they were not having sufficient food.

By the Bench—Supposing the ponies had been given as much food as Mr. Maitland ordered they could not have got into such a condition. They all showed symptoms of -starvation and all recovered when the plaintiff was dismissed.

His Lordship said he had before him the plaintiff's account stating that certain amounts were supplied and whether they were supplied or not, Bir. Nelson had to connect the two.

Mr. Nelson said there was no doubt that the plaintiff had been starving the ponies and robbing his master for some time. If His Lordship thought on the evidence that anything was due to the plaintiff he would ask him to withhold his judgment and he would sue the plaintiff in the Mixed Court for damage done to the ponies. It was not a question of amount with Mr. Maitland at all. He brought the case in the interest of: spoxt and to prevent -if possible other foreigners being imposed upon.

Plaintiff again davied starving the ponies and called a mafoo who had charge of-a Jady's pony kept in the same stable, This witness stated that the ponies were all fed according to orders received.

His Lordship reserved judgment.

12th May. Docrer v. Synva.

This was an, action in which Alexander Doctor, trading as the Mercantile Collecting Agency, sought to recover from the defendant, J. A. Sylva of 12, Canton Road, the sum of $66.90, on a debt due to a Chinese butcher which had been assigned to the plaintiff.

Defendant said he owed some part of the account but would like to see the foreign pass book.

His Lordship (addressing plaintiff)—I seo this is an assignment to the Mercantile Collecting Agency but I shall want proof that you are the agency.

Plaintiff—I am the only member of that firm.

His Lordship—You must prove that to me before I can allow you to proceed. This is evidently a debt duo to Tsin Tsong.

Plaintiff—It was.

i Have you paid for it The assignment is made tothe Mercantile Collecting Agency and.the summons is taken out in the name of A. Doctor. Therefore I dismiss the summons and you must take out another. Pere is no reason whatever why Tsin should not bring the suit himself.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account