The Archive · 1900

Taxation in Ireland

The question raised by Me. Arthur O'Connor was of course the old one on which a Royal Commission sat in 1894, with the result that Irelan t declared to be overtaxed. taxes are of course exactly the same as those imposed in Englind and Scotland; but it ix recognised that in one sense they do bear harder on Ireland than on England. Io the first place, in spite of graduated death duties and everything else, the poor man pays a much larger proportion of his income in taxes than the rich. Consequently and, being a poor country, pays a lazyer amount of taxation in proportion to its wealth than England does. Then the Irish are large consumers of whisky, while the English drink beer, which is much more lightly taxed. It' was very sitivfactory, however, that the Chancellor of the Exchequer was able to show that the disparity rapidly disappearing. Ireland is. rapidly ing in wealth and prosperity, emis showing a decided decrease, and it is hoped. that the next census may show an actual increase of population. Asto the over-taxation of Ireland which the Royal Commission put_on evidence, it is, as Sir Michael Hicks-Beach pointed out, very difficult to see how it can be dealt with. It would not do to impose different taxes in Ireland from those imposed in England and Scotland; that would promote endless dissatisfaction in all thie countries.

'The only means apparent is to lessen the tax on whisky, and cheap whisky, as Siv pointed out, would surely be a curse ty Ireland. The most interesting incident in the discussion was, however, a little altercation between Mr.' Juhuston of Ballykilbeg and Me. Crilly. The latter was vigorously interrupting one of the speakers when Mr. Johnston called out, "Ah! you are drunk." The Speaker was of course appealed to, but before he could intervene Mr. Johnston had withdrawn the charge, an act of courtesy which was acknowledged ith overwhelming effusiveness by Me. Crilly. Altogether it was a lively night in the Commons.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account