v, Emens.
This was the adjourned hearing of this case, wherein the ownership of certain land at Sivza was disputed. The plaintiffs were not now represented, but Mr. E, Nelson (Messrs. Stokes and Platt) appeared for the defendant.
His Honour said—The Court adjourned last Thursday on the motion ofthe defendant that the case should be dismissed on the pleadings. On them I give my decision. As the plaintiffs in this case are Chinese, and as it is evident that the real defendants are Chinese and that Mr. Emens only acts as trustee, the case is purely a cause for Chinese decision. As, however, a foreign title deed had been gotten through this Consulate under circumstances on their face peculiar, I went into the city myself, to find if this deed had been issued on a full knowledge of all-the facts by the Chinese authorities. It appears that the Tsai family land has been the subject of exhaustive litigation in the Chinese Courts, and that a decision had been made giving the land to the parties represented by Mr. Emens in this deed in question, and awarding to the plaintiffs in this suit certain money compensation. From this decision there could be no appeal in the Chinese Courts. The plaintiffs have been notified repeatedly of this decision, and that the money awarded is in the Chinese Court to their demand upon their signing releases as ordered by that Court.
It cannot be asked of this Court that it shall pass upon Chinese cases already
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.