The Archive · 1908

8. J, EDWARD

Stanley James Edwards was charged for that he on November 25, 1907, thea being employed as a clerk or servant to Messrs, Hall & Holts, Ld., feloniously fraudulently did embezzle and steal m of $23.10 in money and within six calendar months thereafter, to wit on December 5 and December 31, 1907, and on January 10, 1908, the further sum of $226.68 in money, to wit money received or taken into possession by him in the name or on the account of his said masters or employers, contrary to the Larceny Act 1861, Star. 24 and 25 Viect., c. 96, sect. 68.

The hearing of this case was resumed at 2.30 p.m.

Mr. R. E, Gregson prosecuted accused was defended by Mr. T. Morgan Phillips.

R. Palmer, recalled, identified an old ledger containing the beginning of the suspense account as connected with this case. The first credit entry was on December 11, 1906; the first debit entry was dated December 24, 1906. Witness pointed out th dall's account in th 5 entry in red showed that the customer would come in to pay. There were no entries of payments. " Suspense, no trace of money" was written in by Mr. Kimpton some time since January 31. The receipted accounts were dated November 25, but there was no corresponding counterfoil in the rough reference book. Nor was the payment entered in the shraf's book, or cash book, or any other book of the Company. Turning to Hocking's account witness went through the books in the same manner, with the same result. The bottom of Mr. Hocking's bill had been cut off. Witness also went through Landers' and Newman's accounts in the same way.

After the] soci books had been gone ito in this way accused was called upon for an explanation. Witness wrote " letter to him, to which no reply was received.

Cross-examined—Witness identified is letter, dated February 25, stating that no less than $2,600 was unaccounted for, and asking for an explanation the following day. The chit-book was signed " Mr. Edwards cannot read, jitials. Witxyes were affected at the time. No-one called upon accused officially from the Company. Mr. Vine wrote to accused, dismissing him, on March 4. There was no necessity for any farther effort for an explanation. Witnese saw a letter from accused to the Board of Directors, dated from the Norsing Home, and complaining that his dismissal was unjust as at the time h had received the Company's letters he was neither able to read nor write, and no one had called to ask him for an explanation. Accused never expressed unwillingness to take up the post of cashier. Since taking it scoused had complained that the work was too mach for him and had asked for an assistant. the Some ime previously there had been two foreigners in the cashier's office. At that time there were two cash registers in the office; one from A to L, the other from L to Z. This system was found unworkable. They did not revert to one foreigner in the cashier's office chiefly to cut down expenses. There was now a new the rough reference book, each payment being initialled by the shroff, Witness had heard of Edwards handing over the cash at odd times during the day and receiving a receipt. He had never heard of other cashiers having done so. It was not a convenient practice. 'The credit of the suspense account was very much longer during Edwards' time, amounting once to some $1,300. Witness had frequently complained to the No. 1. shroff upstairs that payments of accounts that had been sent out were not coming in satisfactorily. He had also complained that the money was being held back by the shroffs. He had never made complaints about money shroff he would go to the compradore about him, because he believed be was holding money back. Witness knew that accused had paid his passage home about the beginning of November. Witness and the manager knew about it.

Chang Tien-sang stated that be was shroff in Hall & Holtz, When the bills were ready to go out witness entered them in book and gave them out to the shroff to collect. (Identified his book.) He had nothing to do with the shroff in the cashier's office. He deseribed how entries were made in the rough reference book.

This concluded the evidence for the prosecution.

Mr. Phillips said that he gathered the case was going further, and in these circumstances he did not to into the case io this Court His Worship adjourned until 2 p.m. next day to prove the charges against ced

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account