Tue "South China Morning Post" of the 18th instant contains a very interesting report of an interview with Mr. William Maxwell, the war correspondent of the London "Standard," who was passing through Hongkong, homeward-bound. What Mr, Maxwell said throws " good deal of light on the war correspondent ques, tion, valuable light, because he re-ented the "Standard" at the front in Marchuria from the first battle on the Yalu to the fall of Port Arthur. I is clear from what he said that much injustice has been done the Japanese by the correspondents, who left the field after the battle of Liaoyang. "I would like to remove," he says, "the impression which seems to be very common, that the, Japanese at the front gave no facilities to the foreign war correspondents for observation. At the beginning of the war there were many things which might have gone better, and this impression of opposition was created by the fact that many of the correspondents left after the battle of Liaoyang. They had to make oura good case for leaving, and they did so by accusing the Japanese of placing serious difficulties in the way of independent observation: I repudiate in the strongest possible manner the statements that the Japanese prevented us from seeing everything that could legitimately be seen of any action in which the Japxnese were engaged. After the first fight at Motieoling (?) we had every opportunity that a correspondent or attache could desire to witness the operations." Mr, Maxwell is justly contemptuous of the griffins who were always clamouring to be allowed to join the firing line, the worst place they could get to see anything of the battle as a whole, if they had. pluck enough to stay there when they got there. "No one can possibly see more than a brigade in action at one time if it is firing." Asa matter of fact, the Japanese, teste Mr. Muxwell, went farther and took more trouble than avy army he has ever known. The Staff gave the correspondents lectures on the operations, and supplied them with valuable material, and took great pains to do it. The great trouble, and this is known to-everyone who is conversant with the question at all, was that all sorts of unqualified, ignorant, inexperienced, and incom. petent persons.were accredited in a hurry as correspondents by newspapers at home. These men wanted to make a name for themselves, and did not. care what promises and engagements they broke, sp long as they obtained credit for getting their dispatches through quickly. "If a correspondent breaks his.pledge of honour and rides away to send off uncensored dispatches, he can do so and will doubtless obtain a momentary credit and reputation; but the effect on the profession' is.disastrous, Every Attache, British and foreign, has taken notes of these things, and we may be sure that in any future war either there will be no correspondents, or the greatest care will exercised in their selection... The whole of the war, from the correspondent's point of view, has been disastrous, chiefly owing to the conduct of the majority of the men. No other army in the world would have tolerated it, and I am sure that no mao would have attempted the same methods with a European army, for he would have been instantly punished. The Japanese seemed to have some reluctance to inflict punishment for infringement of their rales, and some men were not slow to take advantage of this immunity." The fact is, that there were many in the scratch pack of correspondents who could not dispossess themselves of the mistaken idea that they were representatives of a superior race, and: The British War Office threatened treatment; and the Japanese were so determined to make an unimpeachable record in their first: serious encounter with a Western Power, that they tolerated conduct which a Western Power would have very promptly repressed.
Mr. Maxwell names among those who certainly. played the game Mr. Donohue of the "Daily 'Telegraph," Mr. Mackenzie of the "Daily Mail," Mr. Knight of the "Morning Post, Mr. Palmer of "Collier's Weekly,' and Mr, Collins of Reuter's: he went on to say:—
With regard to the correspondents with the First Army, a number of men went away and have written books and been interviewed who never were with the army in the field and who never aaw a shot fired. They have spread rej j of the treatment of eorrespondenta which are entirely without foundation, and they have done so in order to create the impression that they were at the front and were compelled to retire owing to alleged: ro-strictions. Two correspondents with* the Rassian army, one American and one British, who remained in Liavyang after the fight, were escorted to the nearest telegraph' office, from whence they sent their messages—a privilege which had not been granted to any correspondents with the Japanese army. They went off immediately afterwards to the Russian army. This ought never to have been allowed, and was not only unfair to the correspondents with the>Japanese but prejudicial to were abedlutely Dbaseloes, as Dr. Wertwater, spree of looting in rang whic footing Lisoyacg whish
the Scotch missionary, and the only European who knows what happened, testified, The Japanese should tained those two men and sent them back to their respective countries.
Mr. Maxwell is deservedly severe on the correspondents. who threatened to avenge themselves on the Japanese by joining the Russians, They, he says, should be shot. as spies, as Sir White would have shot them; and, the men who sought to provide "daily sensations for their employers by discovering details which any army would endeavour to conceal were equally no better than spies. "Again, he draws attention to the cor dents who, having been Volunteer officers, made use of their rank which they would never dream of doing in England.:"One newspaper whose correspondent was a Volunteer Artillery officer, published his name and gave him the brevet rank of Major. who therefore expected reverential ' to deprive him of his commission if he did not discontinue publishing his name with such rank. We had not a single man among the correspondents who had ever been in the British army or any army, yet it was Captain This and Major That." As regards Port Arthur, Mr. Maxwell agrees with Dr. Morrison that it was a disgraceful surrender, for which there was no adequate military reason. He entirely sympathies with the garrison, and recognised that. it was not they, but their General, who surrendered. The siege, he points out, lasted only 148 days, one month longer than Ladysmith; and of the troops who surrendered, 23,000 were in a con-
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.