The Archive · 1920

Open Air Concerts

Qui excuse s'accuse. And the same result may sometimes ensue from endeavours to excuse other people. Which is merely preliminary to saying that we must regretfully disagree in toto with the views advanced by our correspondent on the subject. of open air concerts. No one un der rates the good work that M. Paci did last winter nor wishes 10 do violence to the artistic temperament. But because a man can conduct a Beethoven symphony with a full orchestra sloes not appear to exempt him from conducting light music with an incomplete band when that happens to be the work he is brid to do. And if the band is incomplete, the greater reason why the best conducting is necessary in. order to make good other inevitable lo ficiencies. We see no reason why M. Paci should not conduct the open air concerts and it would be interesting to know why he has not hitherto done so, As for the "stupendous task of a conductor while rehearsing." much of what the band has been giving this summer it has been playing for years past, while the rest of it is not of the kind that ought to trouble an. musician worth employing. He: Buck was doubtless "'a horrid German,"' but no one will deny that he was a first-class musician, who none the less regularly conducted the open air concerts, as well rs performances on race days. He may not have liked it, but he did it thoroughly ani conscientiously just as scores of other men Shanghai are doing what they dislike because it is their duty. We are sorry to speak sharply. But, if the concerts were very good in the winter, they are now very poor. And there are_only five a week. Why none on Fridays and only one on Saturdays, even though Tune is well forward?

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account