The Archive · 1928

Precedent for Request

In addressing this reasonable request to the board of directors, 1 think we are on quite safe ground; by way of precedent elsewhere I night mention that a similar request was made by a number of sharcholders in the Hongkong and Wham ea Dock Ca. Ltd. Hongkong a little over a year ago. The directors welcomed the proposal and a committee of four -shareholders was duly appointed and in due course. discussion and gentlemen have any other sugges. any of you tions to make, Ishall be very glad if yoy will do-so, will read to you the letter we propose sending in to the of directors and if you approv€ of the wording, I should like you to give me. the ames of the gentlemen who ard willing to serve on the committee that we can, if possible, appoint the committee today. The letter will then be ready for signature by all who are in favour of this pro-

The question was raised by a member" present as to whether the committee would be confined entirely to those who are_already on the register of the Company, suggesting that those who were later ce-opted should be those holding shares before the closing of the books of the Company.

The Power to Ca-opt Mr, David Arakie thought otherwise. He maintained that "there should really be no hard and fast rule regarding the composition of the committee of inquiry. It should bbe drawn in more. ways than on As one whom the chairman of the meeting recommended should be {included on the committee of inquiry, he felt that no undue re-Striction should be. placed. on. th committee, The latter could have Power to ce-opt any non-shareholder or shareholder who became one after the recent closing of the books. It] could invoke the assistance of any man or body which could render it assistance in diagnosing the trouble, Of course, in the case of technical men whose ce-operation was essential in understanding the "yarn ection, for instance, it could be ranged that "no gentleman. from competing mill "would be ap-Proached.

Mr. -Armbold told the meeting that every assistance would no daube be rendered by the general managers to the committee in the investiga tions, but in the case of technical men these were few.

'Mr. Arakie-said that it was material whether the investigating committes were composed of two or more men. While he. approved for the. suggestion. of "the chair. man that it might be restricted to four, Mr. Arakie felt that n body of two' men willing to devote their

management would answer the pur-time io "exploring! the whale mi pose, He felt that if the suggestion of a committee of inguiry were approved of in principle by the directors it would go a'tong way in sisting the meeting.

The Chairman agreed with Mr. Arakie in not restricting the mem= bership on the committee of inquiry to shareholders already-on the resister of the company.

Mr. Arnold deplored the writing of anonymous letters to the Press, which he maintained did not get one anywhere.

The Chairman assured those pre-mut that he hed not written any such anonymous letters to the Press while Mr, Arakie also" mentioned that he came into the picture the eleventh hour, and although deprecated the writing of anonymous characterised he letters to which he Press,

welcomed the opportunity to assist the Company in unravelling the prolem of losses on the working of the mill, He did not wish to pose fas an obstructor but one who felt the need to do something to save the company.

Eventually it was decided that} the Committee at the first stage should comprise Messrs, W. Blenk and David Arakie, with powers to ce-opt from time to time and in any manner they desired.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account