The Archive · 1932

GENEVA BATTLE BEGINS Discuxsion on Shanghai Situation

Geneva, Feb, 9.

The Council of the League of Ni tions was engaged for several hours today in discussing the situation at Shanghai, but no. resolution "was passed. In summing up the debate, M. Boncour, the Chairman of the expressed. the opi hon that the whole affair seemed te the result of a lamentable: Understanding. "At presen fuge of procedure, the Council must remain vigilant and await further reports, As the members of the Council were leaving, the Chinese Minister to Berlin, one of the delegates to ithe Disarmament Conference, creat ed a scene just outside the Cou Chamber by vociferously protest ing against the action of the President of the Council in closing the debate without giving the Chinese delegate an opportunity of replying to Jupanese allegations with reference to the Chinese boycott.

The Minister was very excited and spoke incomprehensible French. No tone in the crowd could understand a word of what he said, bat Reuter, through another Chinese delegate, obtained the substance of the remarks.

The Minister angrily declared that the Japanese allegations were Founded and were intended to incite the other Powers to adop they [Japanese methods.

Dr. W. W. Yen, the Chief Chinese delegate, said U ree the, last meeting of the Council it had been announced that Britain and Amer ica were taking steps to stop host lities. Ie then read the statement] made by Me, J. H. Thomas, the British Secretary for the Dominions, previous to the opening of the Disarmament Conference, and remarked that that statement had since received sinister confirmation.

Troops Flow into China Japanese troops, he. said, were! flowing' in ever-increasing measure foceupie There were, he Into China, "In Manchuris they had

declared, 75,000. Japanese soldiers Manchuria and' 25,000 in Shang-ai, while there were 27 transports ready to move upon Chi He declared there was no sign of any change in Japan's "intention, The situation was already. critical and would become more critical.

He then read despatches showing. the evolution of events in Shanghai which were, paralysing commerce that city. The latest event was the bombing of an ambulance and the wounding of an American lady om an errand of mercy.

This state of affairs he described Jas intolerable, not only to China but to the League Powers.

Dr. Yen continued that the self-restraint and moderation shown China under these conditions did) not need emphasis. There was, how: ever, a limit beyond which fion "could go and China could not yield forther without compromising While faithfully adhering to the solemn engagement taken with other nations, she had bean compel Ted to exercise the unquestioned right self-defence Inherent in" every. Sovereign state and to take such mes sures of self-defence as lay within the compass of her man power and natural resources.

Dr. Yen declared that, if need be, her people would not hesitate to make the supreme sacrifice.

Concluding, Dr. Yen remarked that he had no desire to complicate unnecessarily a situation already ldiscouragingly complex and, therefore, before considering other steps he invited a frank expression views with the object, if possible, lof bringing about immediate ces tion of Japan's hostile action and the prompt withdrawal of her arm-jed force on Chinese territory.

Japanese Reply replgs said the Counc the chief Japanese dele-not agree regarding the There was also much ex-regarding the number of troops in Manchuri He had not failed, he said, to Jcomimunieate to the Council all' the details in the posyesion of his Government which was most anxious to municate full and exact infor-motion to the Council.

As regards the facts of the situation at Shanghai, he said that two days ago he had received a report which gave an account of all that Thad happened at Shangh:

Me. Sato continued: "You have not Feferved to the Shanghai report, but T shall. It is a very clear fund straightforward report, which T claim supports all the reports I have submitted to the Council. See-ting we have received the first part Jot the report I. believe we should inder. 1 therefore feel that it is unnecessary for met to reply to the charges just made by Dr. Yen, but T will nevertheless Fegarding the Jevents at Shanghai."

Mr. Sato added that the Powers had made suggestions, to. the Chi nese and Japanese Governments, "My Government", he stated, "in: structed jis representative at Shanghai to negotiate with the Powers. 'These' negotiations concerned three points, which were "communicated Nerbally. 'The first proposed the stopping of the troops at a. line assigned to us, the second insisted pon our advérsuiea "withdrawing in order to. id contact, the third dealt. with' the creation of a neutral, zone between us, which zone would be administered neutrally. I suggest that the question by whom this" zone should. be administered] should be discussed. locally where they are belter qualified than we! here to form a judgment.'

Mr. Sato expressed the hope that 'a settlement on the spot would be reached very quickly, The new admiral, he said, had been instructed to bring about a cessation of host ities.

The remarks by Mr. Sato that Japan didn't intend to continue hostilities at Shanghai and was enxious for a settlement aroused "t-credulous murmurs among the audi fence and the President was forced to rap the table in onder to secure order.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account