The Archive · 1932

A Faint Hope

Is there a faint hope that Shanghai will be spared the hor-yors of a further—and more ter rible—clash of arms? It is very! faint; even now as these, lines are being read it may have di appeared; but it has gleamed an instant in a lowering sky. It may not: be just a mirage from the spirit of the brief truce arranged for the rescue of Chapel Yefugees. The factors in favour of It are the earnest goodwill of all the neutral powers, the growing conviction that Shanghai is faced with a more serious threat to its very existence than ever' yet known; Chinese and Japa ese alike recognise this. They oth have the most pressing reasons for striving at all costs to avert it. The significance of the trade stoppage, of the grim tale of destruction and of the massing of huge armied forces on the Settlement's boundary starkly apparent, It is tending to reverse many judgments of the balance of the various possibilities confronting the interested parties.

Of what profit is victory to one side or the other if it gained at the cost of the virtual disappearance of Shanghai as world-city'? Can vindication or chastisement, for one moment be worth the jettisoning of so much. material prosperity, so much' moral stamina? At this critical stage in the history of civilisation, the crippling or destruction of Shanghai would be a crime! against which the mere assertion of. physical ascendancy would be as dust in the balance. Obstacles are the natural workings of the ever-potent influence of prestige. On the Japanese side there is the need for repairing damage to. military reputation. The Chinese feel that success, limited and ephemeral though it be, has! strengthened the ease for resistance, Elsewhere it is felt that apparently indeterminate issue out of the present aflictions would place the Settlement in an impossible position.

Against this me of argument there is operating on the side of humanity, the practical fear lest even victory itself may be as dead sea fruit. Sober Chinese! opinion, placing the value of the: Settlement's integrity as an asset to be safeguarded at all costs and recognising that, too high an estimate can be made of recent checks to Jupanese operations, is displaying a reasonable readi ness to find a peaceful solution, regardless of the risk of being charged unfairly with a Inck of spiritual it China pride, The risk is not great for,

has gained so much that she can afford to display the supreme moral courage of renunciation. What of Japan?—there the problem is difficult but, again, not impossible of solution. Japan Incks no moral courage. That quality, exercised by a great nation in a supreme moment of destiny, can override—hitherto cherished notions of prestige Tt can, indeed, transcend them and exalt the men and the eountry big enough to display it. There would be no talk of tory on one side or the other but the common glory of a grand abstention. Neutral friends of both are willing to lend a hand Is it too late?

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account