The Archive · 1932

A Sane Outlook

Feb, 15.

Uyeda, the Commander of the ed Japanese forces. is expressed to the representatives of this and other journals yesterday, shows a sane apr ciation of the obligations _imposed by military considerations y a humane public opin with all the necessary reserve which the crisis demands, be said to have built effactively on the foundations which: Vice-Admiral Nomura diffidently Laid on Friday. He looks for a possible peaceful solution with due regard for the:

[not Blink the dangers of the warlike situation now created. He is well-provided physically and /materially to deal with them. All the more reason therefore can there be hope that, at th eleventh hour, the growing desire for ayuidance of further destruction may find fulfilment, precarious though that hope may be. On landing, General Uyeda issued a short statement! intended plainly to link up his Jexpedition with the operations of Rear-Admiral Shiozawa. The device was natural. It need not be too closely examined. The great need at the moment is to discover the ways and means to ithe extrication of Shanghai from the devastating operations. of contending armies, not to discuss acrimoniously the cause of, past events. Therefore it is sufficient merely to register disagreement with the that Admiral Shiosa on January 28 was in essence defensive. Later, no doubt, that point will come under review, in appropriate setting. General Uyeda would not be the man he is if he were to give at this moment the slightest hint of fee ing embarrassed by the events which have brought him here. He has been able, by the deft comination of a gesture of friendship and an unmistakable parade fof strength, to point out clearly the path to peace, It would be folly to believe that his way could be chosen with alacrity by those for whom his words were plainly intended. The events of the last fortnight have undoubtedly awakened such feelings of military elation in the Chinese troops that—not unnaturally—they and, especially, their newly-discovered supporters, ate disinclined to perceive the advantages of a prudent recognition of hard military facts. There has been a definite reali tion by responsible Chinese business men of the seriousness of mistaking a gallant resistance for proof of a capacity to stem the tide of the advance of a modern, fully-equipped and adequate military force of all arms. Various circumstances, polit chological, temperamental material, "have contributed to limit the effectiveness, of this commonsense argument. Is. it possible that General Uyeda' statement will reinforce that argument to good purpose? The 19th Route Army requires to be saved from itself. If it could be permitted to withdraw from the me which it has so. gallantly held, it would" be saved—and honourably saved—to earn the recognition of its countrymen for having given a new meaning to Chinese valour. The ignorance lof the general public, regarding the exact significance' of the or-dorly disembarkation which has taken place during the week-end, should not be exploited to make the officers and men of the 19th Route Army the victims of their own glamour.

General Uyeda shows clearly that Vice-Admiral Nomura spoke with strict accuracy when he em-Phasised that the Government of Japan had enjoined on them both the exercise of the utmost caution in their operations here. The door to diplomatic discussion is not closed. If there could be a withdrawal. from Chapei of the troops, whose presence there has drawn upon that place the horrors of bombardment and bombing, a great point would be gained. "It seems surprising, to all except those with bitter experience of the waywardness of Chinese polities, that, even nov, no real effort seems to have been made to reduce the authority un der which the' Chinese troops are fighting or rather defending themselves from attack, to a lear, understandable, tangible entity. The tragedy of the situation lies, not so much in [the carnage and the ruin of which Shanghai has been the mournful witness, as in the fact that the men and women who have suffered have suffered under no apparent leadership and without the opportunity to look to such leadership for guidance, encouragement' or the order to - desist interests of Shanghai. He does from a patently. hopeless ad-

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account