The Archive · 1932

The Settlements Position

Feb, 10, The important statement issued from the Municipal Council regarding the status of the International Settlement in the] Tight of the present hostilities shows that, for technical reasons which appear to be eminently: sound, the Council is not, in a position to do more than it ha: done in extricating the Set! ment from the embarrassing plight of a tertius non gardens. The Settlement, by convention Detween certain Foreign Powers, has enjoyed a "qualified neutral condition" for defensive purposes, The plan of defence of the Settlement, as put into operation on January 28,. drawn up several months ago. It did not contemplate that its operation would be concurrent with a virtual state of Wav, between China and Japan, The Secretary-General, in giving this legal opinion, was hound to confine himself to the legal responsibilities of the Council. He was therefore plainly compelled to mako the statement that the allotment of the vane tional units to their particular] sectors was not within those responsibilities. It clearly anated from the military experts of the Defence Committee, on which until a week ago, the Chairman of the Council served, and_on which the Commissioner of Police, and the Commandant of the Shanghai Volunteer Corps! have served and still serve, together with the British, American and Italian Commanders. The Japanese command was also represented on the Committee up. to and including January 27, when it is understood that the arrangements for defending the Settlement were discussed. After that date, except for one specific occasion, it is believed that the Japanese' representative did not attend. Although therefore the Council is free of legal liability for the disposition of the Settlement's defence, it probably would not be ed, on that. account, to suggest that the plana were in themselves unsuitable, bearing in mind-their origin and the circumstances of their application, It is plain, however, that the defence scheme, in the light of the emergency unexpectedly produced, was inappropriate and, in fact, has considerably com: plicated the whole situation. Admiral Shiosawa foresaw this when he waived his right to command the defence forces. That act of courtesy was also an act of recognition of the difference between his own standing and those of his brother commanders. He was concerned with the plans with which he had been entrusted by his Imperla] Government and not solely with the defence of the Settlement, Indeed his proclamation demanding the withdrawal of the Chinese troops from Chapei, accompanied as it was by the threat of. measures" justified his decision to hold aloof. Therefore, while the British and American and Italian commanders put their sectors into the necessary state of defence, the Japanese plans were laid on other lines. The events of January 28 onwards, as outlined in the colourless reports of the League of Nations Conmislover, cannot proceed much be-In issues, where complicated Sino-Japanese relations, They yond the stage of friendly reappreciate, however, the solid ad-monstrance. The Japanese Govmatic position and constitutional vantages to be gained by refrainernment has-been asked by practice are involved, it is easy Foreign Powers to give assur jon the ignorance of the general ing from any movements or re-ances' on this point. Those public. It is difficult for the presentations which, so far from. assurances have obviously but a authority attacked to dispose of maintaining those advantages for limited value in' the face of the the anxieties of well-intentioned effective use in the ultimate mo-reports presented to the League friends by a clear-cut definition. iment of conference, will inevitably land im the light of daily hap-But, in sober truth, the legal dissipate them, without achieving Jpenings here. Operations in the Inicetics of the position become: more than a general disaster. On Settlement for the defence of lof academic interest only in a this consideration, perhaps, the the lives' and property of time of such special poignancy, tegrity of the Settlement rests nationals are one thing. Opera-except to those who seek to make more securely than present contions for the infliction of punish-them political capital for' ment or for the purpose of [ditions appear yet to warrant. some near or distant future instituting reprisals against a jeasion. The main issue really third party outside the Settle-is the integrity of the Settl ment are quite another. The ment. All are agreed that it Japanese Government las now should be safeguarded at all

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account