The Archive · 1936

First Things First

Aug. 20.

The suggestion that foreigners were favourable to the idea of meeting demands made to them under the Income Tax Law which was approved by the. Legislative Yuan on July 9, has been tentative ly put forward in the Chinese press lately. "In extension of this picture which surely puts human, if not foreigners, nature in a surprisingly new light, an interview with Mr, R. Calder-Marshall, the Chairman of the British Chamber of Commerce produced in the Chinese press the impression that if there was one desire burning more flerce~ ly in the breast of the British re~ sident here it was to pay the dues: alleged to be assessed as owing by him under the new Law, notwithstanding the privilege of extrater~ ritoriality. Mr. Calder-Marshal! has very promptly and properly pricked this Ingenuous bubble, So far from encouraging the notion that his fellow-countrymen would be prepared to waive their rights and submit to assessment, he pointed out, the practical difficulties in the way of collecting the tax at all and, it is to be hoped that his friendly] hints will be taken, The Chinese Government should not be content with the promulgation of an Income Tax Law which is a virtual dead lelter—or is only applicable to those unfortunate servants of the Government from whose incomes the tax can be deducted at the source.

For one thing, the resultant proceeds would be infinitesimal and in putting forward: the tax the Government's hope is to substitute selentifle for "illicit" methods of taxation, Therefore it is reasonable to assume that what Mr.

Calder-Marshall calls a nation-wide] and effective system is intended.

Theoretically the income-tax_is ideal form of taxation—it the epithet can "be applied without lncerating the assessee's: feelings. Practically its application demands cautious recognition of the social conditions prevailing. Even highly organized countries in the West} have found it Impossible to adopt that direct method of taxation. For China, if the income-tax is to be successfully levied, it seems highly desirable that its initiation should] be on the simplest lines, after approved and competent machine: for assessment and collection has been established. It has been airily remarked that the Government has created a Bureau for the purpose. No evidence is adduced of the for-motion of a trained and adequately' pald body of collectors. There is nothing to show that such a bureau judging from past experience—will be anything more than what} is known as a "farming" concern. If that apprehension be correct then the difference between the bureau's operations and those! methods of illicit taxation which the Government rightly seeks to abolish is merely a distinction and) nothing more. Dr. K. M, Marx, lately showed how vague was the law in certain aspects. Taking me from other countries the Government is believed to intend to} exempt agricultural incomes from assessment for the purposes of the tax, The actual provision for this exemption is not at all clear. Yet, obviously, it is highly necessary comparative simplicity in imposition of the new tax is to be achieved. The need for careful consideration of this and other points is imperative. Without, desiring in the slightest degree to the Central Govern~ food faith in this matter, it] is impossible to be satisfied resent that the requisite conditions for the smooth collection of the tax have been established.

'Western procedure and methods assessment must be cited with dif dence. Perhaps jit may be permissible to lay down certain' principles, the most important of which is that, when a tax of this kind is first imposed, it were better {to err on the side of leniency. In other words the minimum income subject to assessment should be fairly high and the graduation of the tax should be gentle. For instance it has been held that, in country of China's size and popula tion when agricultural incomes are exempt, a 2% per cent. tax on annual Incomes of not less than $2,500 and not more than $5,750 would be reasonable. On incomes between $5,760 and $12,000, the tax might be 3 per cent, It will be seen that this system does not adopt the English method of taxing on the surplus of income over a certain figure, but the lower percentage of the assessment more than compensates for that difference. This would appear to be '2 far more workable scheme than that which is now proposed in apparent disregard of the relation of the collections to the cost of effect ing them. Although, leaving out of account the income-lax on business Profits, the rate of assessment of the personal income as proposed by the new Law is not as high as that the scheme already cited, it ean-not be considered practicable in view of the dimensions of the prob-em of dealing with over 1,700 hsiens and petty incomes incom-_ mensurate altogether with the cost collection. Unless the tax be equity ably imposed and levied it will xetara rather than help the Government's admirable efforts at fiscal reform.

These criticisms of the tax do not logically affect the position of the extraterritorial foreigner. His ability to the tax is subject to diplomatic interpretation of the! Treaties. There is no reason why he should act independently of that interpretation. But the feasibility of imposing this tax under present conditions on the non-agricultural population of China is a problem urgent importance. As Mr. Calder-Marshall pointed out, the collection must" be universal, equitable, and effective. The Government cannot afford to be accused of allowing one province to escape and insisting on the full rigour of the Jaw in another provines. ts assessing and collecting machinery must therefore be established beyond doubt before the factual levying of the tax is begun.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account