The comment by this journal on the statement issued over the signature of the Archbishop of York and a number of clergy of the Church of England concerning the alleged moral deterioration of British policy has aroused much bitter comment and some support. It is inevitable that this should be the case, but, despite that criticism there seems|s to be no really sound reason why this journal should not continue to deplore these utterances on British politics. There was time when the Church undoubtedly dominated the State whether for good or ill is a matter of opinion—but that condition no longer exists and the Church is now only part of that organization, and not even a dominant part. Let it be conceded that on the question of the morals involved in the issues raised Dr. Temple is on perfectly sound ground: how valuable a contribution is the statement in question in view of that fact, and some others which are to be adduced?. If all the leader: of the Church in their approach to mundane politics were consistent, its value might be inestimable, but unfortunately even the leaders do not see eye to eye on the question of the application of morality in this connection. During May the House of Lords had occasion to debate on the question of Aby sinza in which the Archbishop of Canterbury, Member of the House of Lords, and His Majesty's Right Hon. Privy Council, advocated suggestions that a settlement of the Abyssinian question might be reached by installing Emperor Haile Sola: in some part of the territory formerly his, as a kind of provincial governor owing allegiance to Italy. The following is taken from speech:—
It would be a condition of any such offer that the Emperor would be prepared to forgo his title and undertake to do his utmost to prevent, or, at rate, restrain, organized fighting under recognized chiefs. That fighting is going on, It is going on continually and with ever-recurrent intensity. It must impose a very severe strain upon the nerves of the Italian troops. The maintenance of the large forces needed to deal with it must be an increasing burden upon the resources of the Italian Government. If it could be made to cease, or even be greatly reduced, then the Italian Government would be set free to consolidate that large part of Abyssinia which would then be in its effective possession.
Is this an example of the same devotion to high ideals in politics as that expressed by the Archbishop of York? Or is it not rather a case of holding the candle to the devil of expediency, a bowing down in the house of Rimmon?
And if it is, and it must be remembered that the Archbishop, in the House of Lords was speaking as a Lord Spiritual, who is to be followed—the Archbishop of York. with his stern adherence to the moralities even though the heavens fall, or the Archbishop of Canterbury whose venture into the kingdom of realism seems to err to the other extreme?
Is it not apparent that members of the Church must themselves remain confused in the face of such contradictory doctrines. If there could be unanimity of opinion amongst the leaders on the subject their utterances, might be of some value as a guide to the apparently somewhat less enlightened, but if there cannot be, surely the apparent reticence of the Bishop of London, a Lord Spiritual and member of the Privy Council, affords an example which might with profit be adopted. The view taken by the journal is emphasized by the remarkable utterance attributed to the Bishop of Waikato, in New Zealand, in his charge to the Diocesan Synod, arguing that the admission of Japanese into New Zealand and North Australia would be a fresh, bloodless and altogether satisfactory means of defence. He is reported as alluding to Japan as a possible and powerful enemy, questioning Great Britain's ability to guard the Dominions, and- contending that the matter must be regarded from the Christian and not the political point of view. The passages quoted savour, uncomfortably of the martyr-nation theory that, when a nation is sufficiently devoted to the ideals of peace, to accept in quietness any injustice that may! be inflicted upon it, war would be at an end. It is claimed that the impressiveness of such a sacrifice would transform the world. But would it? This journal does not know, and would be more than a little reluctant to put it to the test until the hungry wolf forgoes the submissive surrender of the tender lamb.
"There probably are people who completely believe that such a doctrinegnay prove effi-cacicus, But if they do they are gifted with that simple faith, which, admirable as it may prove in the individual, is hardly to be recommended to the mass.
These are no days for the demonstration of ethical genius: they are times when the display of political common sense is imperative, and that political common sense requires that aggression shall be met with resistance, that preparations for possible attack shall be met by adequate arrangements for defence. Is it to be believed that, international morality being what it is, sweet words can be relied upon to turn aside bellicose intentions? The question has but to be put to be answered. it is perfectly possible to agree that moral considerations should come first, but in a world in which it is "each for himself and the Devil take the hindmost" exactly what sort of morality is to be applied? If Great Britain had initiated the arn race, if she had not imperilled her existence by scaling down her armaments as an unavailing example to others to such an extent that her expert advisers expressed the gravest anxiety, there might be some ground for the admonition implied in the statement originally criticised, but it is not to be believed that Great Britain has been moved by any more immoral consideration then the unhappy realization that the day might come when she might find herself defenceless against her enemies. When all nations are actuated, by moral considerations and the millennium of peace is here even the leaders of the Church may find some common ground upon which to advise governments as th their moral obligations, and in this connection it may be that countries which live by the sword may perish by that weapon, though this is certain—those countries which have no sword are doomed to extermination first. And one last word. There appears to be the impression in the minds of some writers to the correspondence columns that a man's eminence frees him from criticism. It is a poor doctrine, for, if indeed it applied, constitutional officers of State would be sacrosanct, and one of the freedoms of democracy would be denied. Church dignitaries as well as statesmen when they come into the public arena must be prepared to face criticism—even as editors.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.