The Archive · 1941

M. EGAL'S "ARREST"

Aprit 7.

There is a local aspect to the case of M. Egal, who was suddenly removed from his residence on Saturday morning, and is now detained on a French gunboat in the Whangpoo, which is of considerable importance, to all Shanghai, Despite the fact that a French consular court operates in Shanghai it is earned that the French navy appears to have intervened in its jurisdiction, in a man ner which completely traverses usages tablished for nearly a century in Shanghai, It any warrant were issued at all, it cer: tainly was not submitted for counter-signé ture by the Belgian authorities, a proceeding rendered necessary because of the fact that the apartment house in which M, Egal resides is Belgian-owned, Without the declara~ tion of martial law it is doubtful in the extreme if the French Navy or Army could have embarked upon any such proceedings in say Indo-China or any other French colony, thereby assuming the functions of courts al ready in existence, and the conclusion to be drawn is that the whole affair smacks of such illegality that it is no better than any other political kidnapping of which Shanghai has already seen too many.

Shanghai throughout its existence has proved an asylum for all types of political thinking, and in this respect the authorities of the French Concession have been just as liberal as those in control of the Internation~ al Settlement, It is an unhappy fact that at present there is a great division of opinion between those Free Frenchmen who desire to remain loyal to the cause for the defence of which their country took up arms in 1939, and those who support the Vichy Govern ment. But it is necessary to remember that [they are all still Frenchmen, still entitled to that liberty which is one of the watchwords of their great nation, To indulge in such a practice as was witnessed on Saturday is to deny that freedom by an action fraught with Megality, and to establish a most unfortunate precedent. What {s going to happen if the various foreign communities of Shanghai in which there may be differences of opinion fare to witness the various parties Ikidnapping each others' leaders? The question once put, reveals the potential dangers which such conduct as that under review must inevitably invoke, Regarding the whole affair from a purely Jocal point of view, it is difficult to perceive any difference whatever between the forcible removal of M. Egal to the French gunboat, and any of the many political kidnappings which have accursed. If M. Egal has offend-led against any Jaw administered by the French Consular Court, surely the proper remedy can be-obtained by prosecuting him in the manner prescribed by law. There has most certainly been no announcement of the imposition of martial law, by the French authorities in the Concession, and no question fof the Court having been superseded in such 'a manner. It is reported that there is very considerable indignation in French and other les over what has happened. That indignation arises from various causes, but there is certainly ground from the local aspect for condemning an action which ought never to have been taken. may very well be that what has occurred the result of the enthusiasm for their cause which animated those concerned to act in the way they did. That is no excuse whatever. If intolerance is to be carried to such extremes Shanghai may find itself in a grave situation, What is of the greatest importance in such trying days as these is that everyone should seek to maintain order and it is intolerable that any section, no matter how good they believe their cause to be, should behave in a manner which endangers the peace and good order of the foreign areas Jot Shanghai. The only means of curing the present state of affairs with regard to the case of M, Egal is that he should be handed over to the jurisdiction from which he should never have been removed, and that it charges are to be preferred against him, they should be investigated by the proper tribunal, It is only by some such method that the status of the French Consular Court and the rule of law can be vindicated, for it is quite apparent that the kidnapping of M, Egal is completely lawless.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account