Leighton Shields, and counsel for the defence, Mr. H. G. Nelson, completed their arguments before noon, and the Court was thereupon adjourned.
The heating opened when Mr. Shields recalled Lieut. Boyd, who testified that Pfc. Triplet left the et-on Ferry Road at 1.45 pam. on fand returned at 915 pam. He also said that Casement was pres. ent at the inquest into the death of Floyd Allan Sebastian, but did not Wish to testify at that time.
Mr. Shields then started his sum. ming up, ending by demanding the death penalty for Casement. He that in his opening address he expressed the hope that accused would be able to disentangle himsel€ from the web in which he was. caught. He was given every opportunity. to prove hit innocence, being able to listen to the testimony of all wit. nesses during the trial. He showed himself to be of perfectly normal Intelligence, his alertness in parrying questions put in cross.examination proving this.
can well see why he should de. velop the afterthought of an alibi:* he stated, "his drinking buddy, Triplet, would naturally help him a much as. possible." Mr. Shields remarked on the exactness with which all. witnesses for the defence were fable to state the exact times of their movements, this being suspicious in He charged that the evidence of defence Witnesses regarding—the Nimes of days in question, and taking in consideration the probable time of the baby's death were Casement's conception of an air-tight alibi, form. fed from the evidence presented at the Inquest "The testimony of the amah that Casement had gone home and told, liber fo leave, was corroborated by accused's written statement on the day aller his arrest. "How would she know, if it were not a fact, that hho came to the room and said good-night" to her. He admits this in his written statement. He was able to develop his alibi as he sat in Court during the exclaimed the Disiriet Attorney.
"He showed himself to be 2 low-down brute when he looked for his elt in the room when he awoke and found the child' beside him, instead of sending for a de ting help. 1 believe. th cetid go to sleep with a dead body inthe' bed."
Mr. Shields then went over the evidence piece by piece, pointing out that all of Casement's actions show.
desire for concealment. All facts taken together, according to the District Attorney, wove such a web round accused that no doubt could remain that he murdered the child.
After.-Mr. Shields had concluded for the time being Mr. Nelson pre~ sented the case for the defence. He asked what motive Casement could have had for murdering the child, saying that the prosecution had very carefully avoided any mention of a motive. Me then outlined the law in regard to first degree and second degree murder, showing that for con~ vietion it (s necessary to prove that 2 man had the intention to kill, with malice aforethought!. "Is a man in a @runken condition capable of being guilty of first degree murder?" he Baked, "ik is quite possible that Casement' really cannot remember what happened between the hours of 830 pum. and 410 am, the next mort T'submit that the humane vi that aman who is drunk cannot have malice forethought. Tt this Court finds Casement guilty, it should only be of manslaughter."
He added that he thought that Casement's alibi was beyond ques. tion, and' went over the evidence Teading to Unis, His conclusion wi that, according to the medical ovidfence, the baby must have died be. {ween 630 and 720 pin. on March 12, 9 o'clock at.the latest. "The amah knows more about the crime than we do," he said, "she knows more than she told."
The strangest circumstance against accused, Mr. Nelson went on to say, was that his underclothing was cover: ed in blood. It might seem peculiar that a man could wake up to find 2 corpse beside him and rush out of the room" without. doing anything about it. "The question then arose fo how the child got on to the bed. "I submit, Mr. "Nelson declared; that it was dead when Casement ar-
Fived, ard he was so drunk that he was able to get into the bed without Rolicing the body."
He concluded by pointing out an alleged discrepancy in the times be-{ween the alleged telephone call to Bubbling Well Police station report. Ing the crime was made, and. the time when the actual call was noted, Using a map to illustrate his argu: ment.
'Mr. Shields then rase again, and concluded his summing-up in a'short [speech in which he stated that' Mr. Nelson had. only shown by his reference to the map that Gerald Case. ment. was the real murderer of Sebastian. "There Is no. reasonable @oubt that. Casement killed 'Ski er's" he said. He finally' stated that the only thing to do. with Casement was "send him to the chair."
Given Life Term Apr. 8.
Found guilty of murdering Floyd Allan Sebastian, a fifteen months old baby, Gerald E. Casement, Pf, U.S. M. C., was sentenced to life im= prisonment on MeNelll's Island Poni fentlary by Judge Milton J. Helmick esterday morning in the U,. Court for China, after a tell lasting for three days ina packed courtroom. Yesterday's hearing, climaxing the sensational trial, Iasied lasa than five minutes, Casement having nothing to say before judgment was passed. remained. impassive throughout the (rial, and, maintained his composure when sentence was passed.
The court assembled promptly at 0 o'clock, when Judge Helmick gave his verdict. "After earnest. "and solemn consideration of the evidence this ease, and the law involved stated, "this court finds the cused guilty of murder in the second degree."
'Addressing Casement. he asked, "What have you (0 say, if anything' "Nothing." Casement replied.
You will be fernandod in the care of the U.S. Marshal until you can be sent to MeNeill's Island Penitentiary, Judge Helmick continued, "and ther you will be incarcerated for the rest of your natural life." The court was then. adjourned.
Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.