The Archive · 1940

Before Commissioner N. E. Lurton

Shanghai, Feb, 16.

two actions by the Cathay" Lai Ca, Ltd, against American citizens for payment of sums said to be due for rent. for two apartments Grosvenor House, were dismissed by Judge N.E. Lurton, in the US, Consular Court yesterday. The defendants were Clark Vyse, a member of the U.S. Consilate staff in Shanghai, "and George V. Monk, local Anierican businessman, The claim against Mr. Vyse was for $474.72, said to be the amount due for payment of the full amount of rent for Apartment 120%, Grosvenor House for the months of October. November and December 1939 and January 1940. The claim against Mr. Monk was for $984.32, the company Claiming that the defendant had failed to pay the full amount due for rent and electricity for the months of October, November and December 1999 and January 1940 with respect to Apartment 403, Grosvenor House.

oth defendants, whose cases were heard together, were represented by 'Mr. N, F. Allman of Allman, Davis Kops. 'Mz, C.S. Franklin, of' Franklin Harrington represented the Cathay Land Ca, Ltd.

Tu his judgment, Judge Lurton said that on or about March 31, 1999, the plaintiff company despatched a letter: fo. the defendant (Mr, C. Vyse? whereby "it offered to rent to the defendant those premises then cupied by him under a lease to start 31 al a stipulated rental.

On June 13, 1939, the defendant accepted the terms of the plainti company's offer to enter into 2 lease with it for the said premises. The plaintiff company refused to give lease to the defendant and brought suit to recover the sum claimed to be owing to it by the defendant on month to month rental basis.

"The plaintiff, in the meantime, the judgment continued, having notified tthe defendant that his rent would be increased ina sum larger than that stated In its offer of March 31 on a. {ease basis, it also appears that from ithe evidence that the exchange rates [between the U.S. dollar and the pound sterling and the Chinese national dollar took a sudden drop on, June 7 which rendered the Chinese dollar of Tess value.

"Ht is the defendant's contention that the plaintiff was bound by its offer of March 31 to lease him the said. premises at a stipulated rental contained therein after his acceptance fof the said offer on June 33. the contention of plaintiff. that the defendant took too long a time to de-feld the offer of the plaintiff in re-Tation to accepting a lease for the premises and that by reason of the sudden drop in exchange before his acceptance, constituted reasons for the plaintiff to revoke its offer "Applying these rules to the facts this case there appears to be no Jdoubt in the mind of the Court that the time limit was fixed by strong implication. in plaintiffs offer. which gave the defendant until July 1 to Accept the offer of plaintiff Even in considering the question of "reason fable time" had no definite time been fixed, which could have been implied in the plaintiff's offer for the defend~ fant to make up his mind, the time utilized by the defendant was not of such long duration from the date of the offer to bring it within the realm "The only way the plaintiff can object to the time taken by the Sefendant for acceptance of its offer to make it come within the realms of unreasonableness would be duc to of exchange, which waist the plaintiffs interest the rental value. The plaintiff of complain that it was without recourse against the defendant on this point for the following reasons. the exchange dropped on June 7 and the defendant did not accept the offer until June 13.

"The Court conceive why the plainti did not avail itself of its Tight to revoke ils offer to the defendant Immediately after June 7. Wt had six days' time to avail itself lof this opportunity but failed to do So and it appears to the Court that ican be charged with this respect. In this case there was no revocation until, after defendant had accepted—plaintif's offer which the latter refused to per= form.

the present ease there appears to be no question about the fact as to which spoke first, The defendant accepted the plaintiff's offer in writs ing on June 13 and it was not until after that date that the plainti! refused to comply with the defendant's acceptance. The defendant spoke first and it appears to the Court that he was within his rights to demand that the plaintiff carry out the terms of offer. of March 31."

On similar grounds the other action by the company was dismissed.

Text read from the printed page and cleaned; old type leaves the occasional error.

Your account